The first GOP amendment offered was ruled non-germane because it was addressed in the Dem super simple amendment.

The second was tabled on an 18-15 vote, with Sen. Sullivan this time joining his Dem colleagues to thwart the amendment.

UPDATE: 6:02 p.m. -- Another GOP amendment falls 18-15. This one would have removed policy from the budget.

Now being discussed is an amendment to remove all earmarks.

-- By Greg Bump