The URL for the Budget Blog has changed as of Feb. 13, 2009. Click here to visit the new home page

Senate Members


Co-Chair: Sen. Mark Miller, D-Monona

Democratic members Republican members

Assembly Members


Co-Chair: Mark Pocan, D-Madison

Democratic members Republican members

Thursday, June 30, 2005

Amendments Pouring In

Looks like its going to be a long night.

Amendments are tumbling in now. We've reached SA 8, and there are at this minute 36 listed on the Senate in-session page. Adding to the suspense, we have yet to see the GOP super amendment.

Happy Birthday, Mr. Budget Director

As another fiscal year soon fades into history, the Budget Blog would be remiss without a birthday mention for Gov. Jim Doyle's budget director Dave Schmiedicke.

Dave isn't here tonight; he's most likely out engaging in those crazy shenanigans for which budget analysts are famous. Best wishes for many happy fiscal years to come.

Senate Roundly Rejects Tuition Cap

An amendment to cap UW System tuition at 3 percent was rejected by the Senate on a rare vote that didn't break down along party lines. The amendment, SA 5, was authored by GOP Sens. Tom Reynolds and Ron Brown. Democrats Dave Hansen, Lena Taylor and Russ Decker voted with five Republicans.

See the roll call.

Reynolds, Brown Propose 3 Percent UW Tuition Cap

SA 4, the Dems' proposed amendment on Seniorcare, was tabled on - get this - a party line vote.

When roll calls are taken on these amendments, the senators come rushing back to the chamber, then slowly filter back out as the next debate begins.

Currently, a debate on SA 5, a proposal to cap UW System tuition at 3 percent. The amendment is authored by GOP Sens. Tom Reynolds and Ron Brown.

SA 3 Tabled - SA 4 on the Block

The Dems proposal to re-tool pension and retirement benefits and the like, SA 3, was tabled by partisan vote.

Now up for tabling consideration is SA 4, dealing with health care. As Sen. Tim Carpenter tries to sell the proposal, only about a dozen senators are on the floor.

To Adjourn Or Not to Adjourn Is the Question

Senate Dems are trying to adjourn the meeting for the night. Minority Leader Judy Robson said the Republicans "secret super amendment" should be looked at under the light of day. "People are ready to go to bed. We still don't have a copy of the amendment."

A voice vote on whether to adjourn failed, although the "ayes" seemed louder than the "nays."

But Majority Leader Dale Schultz promised the Republican amendment(s) is on its way, and said the session can be completed quickly through diligent work. "I don't think you all want to be here on the weekend."

The Senate is now discussing SA 3, the Democrats' bid to overhaul pension, retirement and disability income in the budget.

Calling 'em Back

Senate President Alan Lasee has begun the roll call to reconvene the Senate. For the record, the ten minute break lasted three hours.

Less Guarded Gard

As the press pack left Sen. Mary Lazich's press conference on the taxpayers protection fund, the press pack ran smack into Assembly Speaker John Gard, who was passing through the corridor with his staff and Majority Leader Mike Huebsch.

Handed the press release for Lazich's taxpayer protection fund proposal, Gard and Huebsch said it was the first time they had seen the language. Asked what he thought of the proposal, Gard shrugged his shoulders and said, "Swell."

"Whatever it takes to get 17 votes I guess," said Gard.

The Peshtigo Republican said of the Assembly leadership's role in the Senate budget process, "We're trying to be helpful where we can." He added he was proud of the work done by the Senate team.

He said he wasn't sure how his caucus will react to the budget after amendment by the Senate, but said, "I'd like to avoid conference committee at all costs."

Sen. Lazich Gives Details on Taxpayer Protection Fund

GOP Sen. Mary Lazich said she was very concerned when she found out earlier this week that spending in the budget bill heading to the Senate exceeded growth, and spent more than spending in Gov. Jim Doyle's bill. So she came up with the taxpayer protection fund. "It's one solution I came up with to make sure that doesn't happen again," she explained during a news conference a few minutes ago in her Capitol office.

Here's how it works: when revenue exceeds the consumer price index plus one percent plus population growth, that excess revenue would be placed into a fund, she said. In order to spend money from that fund, a recommendation from the governor and three-fourths vote of the Legislature would be needed. "In the event of a downturn in the economy, it protects the taxpayer from having to raise taxes," she said.

When the fund exceeds 10 percent of the allowable general fund budget, the excess would be retuerned to taxpayers via income tax cuts, she explained.

Lazich declined to speak about other facets of the Republican amendment. "We don't have anything else totally worked out," she said.

The New Berlin senator was also not quite 100 percent committed when it comes to her final budget vote. "I would like to vote for this budget, and I think I will vote for the budget when we get this done," she said.

See Lazich's press release on the plan.

GOP Senators Look to Create "Taxpayers' Protection Fund"

A major piece of the Republican senators' budget amendment has been revealed. According to Majority Leader Dale Schultz, the amendment will include a "Taxpayers' Protection Fund."

Here's how it will work: Any revenue collected by the state that exceeds the CPI, plus one percent, plus population growth, will be put in an account. Money in the fund cannot be spent without three-quarters vote in the state Legislature and a governor's recommendation.

Schultz spokesman Todd Allbaugh said the Legislative Fiscal Bureau is still working out the numbers for the proposal. He said the account will act like a "rainy day fund" in case of recession or a disaster, or it could be used for property tax relief.

"If the state collects more money than was thought, this is a way to stop it from going to some pork project out there," Allbaugh said. Requiring a supermajority will ensure the cash is spent wisely and will involve bipartisan support, he said.

Democrats have already coined the proposal "the Taxpayers' Deception Fund."

"If this is such a great thing for taxpayers, let's examine it in the light of day," said Kelley Flury, spokeswoman for Minority Leader Judy Robson. She said the Dems may move to adjourn the meeting for the evening when it comes back into session.

Guarded Gard

Ran into Assembly Speaker John Gard in the hallway as he was leaving Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz's office. He was reticent to talk about what the senators are up to with their amendment, or what his role in negotiating a package has been. He also wouldn't speculate on whether an amended Senate budget would be passed in the Assembly. "I haven't talked to any of the members about it yet," he said.

Asked whether the gas tax indexing issue was a sticking point in the negotiations, Gard said he didn't think it was. "The whole budget is a sticking point," he said. "But we've cut the gas tax, for the first time in years, and eliminated the vehicle registration fee increase."

Gard did say while the Assembly won't be in session tomorrow to act on a bill if the Senate acts tonight, citing the logistical difficulties of getting his members back to Madison on short notice during a holiday weekend, but he is eager to get the budget back to his house. "I'd just like to get this done. We got our work done ahead of time. I'd like to get this done as soon as possible," he said.

Shades of Joint Finance

This 10-minute break is starting to feel like the three-hour tour from "Gilligan's Island." Senators have abandoned the chamber, and Senate President Alan Lasee, a stickler for promptness, just walked by with his take-out dinner.

The break was taken to allow time to print the Democrats' third amendment, which is now in the hopper as well as a fourth Dem amendment. It's the Republicans who appear to be the wrench in the works. Word is they're still drafting their amendment, or amendments.

Also, Assembly Speaker John Gard, Assembly Majority Leader Mike Huebsch and Assembly JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert are in Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz's office, which could mean they're still hammering the GOP amendment.

While we wait, have a peek at the Democrats' amendment no. 4.

HOPE Plan Tabled

Senate amendment 2, in which the Democrats tried to introduce their HOPE property tax relief plan, has been tabled by the body on a partisan 19-14 vote.

The Senate will stand informal for the next 10 minutes while they await copies of amendment no. 3. You can check it out at here.

Robson Pushes Schultz for Budget Details

Before debate on the Dems' property tax amendment began, Minority Leader Judy Robson pushed counterpart Dale Schultz for clues on what the Republicans' budget would include.

"We have no idea what's in that amendment," Robson said. "We need to know if we're going to proceed in an orderly way."

"What's the big secret?" she asked.

"I am reluctant to hand out summaries without specific language," Schultz replied. He said handing out a summary early could create the opportunity for more confusion and raise the possibility of a longer delay.

"The idea of 'I'll show you mine if you show me yours' just isn't very appealing," Schultz said.

But he reassured Dems he would give them time to review the amendment once drafting is finished.

Sen. Robert Wirch pushed to see the amendment "in the light of day."

"Let's see this mystery amendment earlier, not at 3'o'clock in the morning," Wirch said.

Education Amendment Tabled

Senate Democrats' amendment to the education budget was tabled on a 19-14 vote.

Next up: Senate Amendment 2, the Democrats' proposed property tax amendment.

Which Party Cares More About Kids?

In the opening rounds of debate over the Democrats' proposed amendment to education funding, former GOP Majority Leader Mike Ellis firmly reminded listeners that it was a Republican Legislature that first approved two-thirds state funding for state schools.

"No one can stand on this floor and accuse Republicans of not being pro-education," Ellis said.

"It was the Republican Legislature ... that took the monkey of the back of the taxpayer for the first time. ... We were the ones who started two-thirds funding of education."

But Democrats were insistent in their criticism of the opposition party.

"The last priority for the Republicans is children and public education," Sen. Robert Jauch said of the JFC's education budget. "This is disgusting ... what's disgusting is that Republicans know it's wrong."

Senate Minority Leader Judy Robson said Republicans were hurting children while simultaneously saying they cared about kids.

"People that hit kids at home say the same things," Robson said.

"You're doing the same thing. ... Why do you have this vendetta against children?" she asked rhetorically.

Schultz Speaks Up

Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz took a few minutes to thank the Joint Finance Committee and his caucus for all their hard work, and the minority party for their patience.

"We have worked hard to reflect the best traditions of this body," he said. He said he hopes that "when we leave here, all the people of this state will know we did our very best."

Opening Salvos

Senate Minority Leader Judy Robson delivered an attack on the GOP budget. "The Republican budget before us does not reflect Wisconsin values. It turns those values upside down," she said.

She singled out increased dollars for the transportation fund, a reduction in education spending from what Gov. Jim Doyle proposed. "The budget is not about children, it is about gifts to special interests," said the Beloit Democrat.

She also pushed for the Dems HOPE property tax relief plan, which she said would close corporate tax loopholes. "Our tax structure is out of whack," Robson said.

The Games Begin

The full Senate has been called to order. The first item taken up is the Democrats' education amendment. The Dems haven't turned over any more of their amendments, and won't until the Republicans' omnibus amendment is drafted and the Dems can peruse it, a staff source said. Expect a break after the Dems' education amendment is voted on.

UPDATE: Shortly after this posting, Dems decided to also introduce their property tax amendment.

They're Back

The Senate will reconvene in five minutes.

Quotable

"Republican leadership - that's an oxymoron." Democratic Sen. Dave Hansen

Schultz on the Run

A few minutes ago, with observers speculating that the Senate Republican agreement may disintegrate over a provision to eliminate gas tax indexing, Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz took a stroll from his office to the West Wing and the office of Assembly Speaker John Gard.

Schultz was not in the mood to answer questions as three reporters followed him down a hall. One asked him if the Senate would be sent home for the weekend, to which he replied he didn't know. Then the reporter asked if the budget bill was headed for conference committee. "If I knew, I wouldn't tell you," said Schultz.

As he walked away, I asked, "Senator, two hours ago you told me that you had 17 votes. Was that premature?"

He didn't turn around.

Hurry Up and Wait

The Senate remains in recess while drafting of the Republican budget amendment continues.

"The Senate will reconvene in an hour ... hopefully," Lasee said somewhat bashfully, prompting loud laughter from Dem Sens. Judy Robson and Jeff Plale, who happened to be in the chamber.

Some are speculating there may be cracks forming in the Republican caucus' 17-vote coalition and that is the reason for the delay.

Wish Lists

Multiple sources are saying part of the Republican amendment is a 5 percent across-the-board cut to all state agencies. If approved, the cut would reduce state spending by approximately $110 million.

Majority Leader Dale Schultz's office would not confirm that the 5 percent cut was part of the package.

The cut is in addition to a number of other "wish list" items under consideration by the Republican Senate to corral the 17 votes needed to pass the budget. Among the potential changes circulating among sources yesterday a 3 percent tuition cap for the UW; a tuition tax credit; lower hunting and fishing license fees and an elimination of gas tax indexing.

More Recess

The hour-long recess has now stretched to two as we await the drafting of the Republican amendment package. Speculation is rampant in the corridors outside the Senate chamber as to what the package entails, with lobbyists and reporters fervently swapping rumors.

Dem Caucus Requested

The session is called to order, and quickly recessed for purposes of a Democratic caucus. The Senate is supposed to reconvene in an hour.

Schultz: "We've Got the Votes"

Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz, headed into the office of Assembly Speaker John Gard shortly after noon with Republican Party of Wisconsin chairman Rick Graber at his side, says the Senate is ready to pass the budget bill. "We've got the votes," he said, shortly before briefing Assembly Republican leadership on the amendment package his caucus created to reach the magic number of 17 votes.

The Richland Center Republican declined to talk about the details of the package, saying he didn't have his notes. "I'd say we're all a little unhappy, and that's a sign we have a good compromise," Schultz said.

Graber was in caucus with the Senate Republicans this morning. Schultz called him an "inspirational figure" in helping reach a compromise.

A spokesman for Schultz said the session will begin with amendments from Democrats while the Republican package is drafted.

Senate Due Back at 12:30 p.m.

Senate President Alan Lasee just announced that the Senate would come to the floor at 12:30 p.m. today. The only item on the calendar is AB 100, the state budget bill.

Asked if this meant Republicans had the votes to pass the budget, Todd Allbaugh, spokesman for Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz, said, "Dale said we weren't coming to the floor until we had the votes, and we're coming to the floor."

New Day, Same Start

Senate President Alan Lasee appeared in the Senate chamber to gavel the floor session to a start then immediately recessed, just as he did yesterday. Majority Leader Dale Schultz's office is promising an update at noon.

Dem Sens. Dave Hansen and Tim Carpenter, wearing a sport coat, polo shirt and shorts with a necktie in his jacket pocket, were here to see Lasee in action. Carpenter invited media to his office for Krispy Kreme donuts.

Wednesday, June 29, 2005

Senate Republicans Still Scraping Votes Together

Today's hopes of a Senate vote on the budget were dashed a short while ago with an announcement by Senate President Alan Lasee that the body will adjourn for the day and reconvene tomorrow at 10 a.m. Optimistically, Majority Leader Dale Schultz had scheduled a noon floor session to tackle the budget, but the Republicans remain in caucus, trying to bring together the 17 votes they'll need for passage.

Schultz sent his communications director, Todd Allbaugh, to the Capitol press room at about 3:20 p.m. He told reporters that the caucus "is in the middle of negotiations." Schultz told Allbaugh to relay to the reporters that the talks were "going well," and the senators would stay into caucus well into the evening if need be to hammer out the details.

"He feels like they're making progress, otherwise they wouldn't be staying here," Allbaugh said.

Budget Session Delayed

Senate President Alan Lasee convened the Senate at noon, then immediately called a recess. Lasee was the only senator present for the "skeletal" session. Opening the session gives the Senate the option to begin a floor session at any time.

Senate Republicans have been caucusing on the budget since 10 a.m. The caucus is also in recess, but will reconvene at 1 p.m.

Around 3 p.m., there will be an announcement whether the Senate will begin the budget debate today or adjourn until tomorrow, according to a spokesman from Majority Leader Dale Schultz's office.

Tuesday, June 28, 2005

Floor Session Scheduled for Noon Wednesday

Senate leadership is planning for a possible floor session tomorrow, but Majority Leader Dale Schultz wouldn't confirm that he has the votes to pass the pending state budget.

"I believe if we work hard and we are smart, we can go on vacation soon," Schultz said, saying there was still time to avoid a weekend session. "By moving today it makes it much more likely that we'll finish on time."

The Senate Organizational Committee today scheduled a floor session for noon tomorrow.

Asked whether this means the Republicans have the votes to pass the bill, Schultz spokesman Todd Allbaugh said, “Dale's characterization is that there is progress being made.”

Schultz didn't discuss specific budget numbers.

“We're at the closing moments of budget negotiations and let me say there is only one number I'm concerned with - 19,” Schultz said, referring to the number of members in the GOP caucus. The next time he will talk specifically about budget numbers, he said, “is when we pass the budget.”

Before the meeting, Schultz' office said Republican senators plan to caucus at 10 a.m. tomorrow. That caucus comes after Republicans spent several hours in caucus today, trying to iron out differences on the budget.

Lazich Looks Like a 'No' Vote on Budget

Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz' job seemed to get a little more difficult today, as Sen. Mary Lazich arose as a possible "no" vote on the budget, even though she voted for it as a member of the Joint Finance Committee.

In an e-mail sent to WTMJ-AM's Charlie Sykes, Lazich said she changed her mind after receiving more information on spending from the Legislative Fiscal Bureau on Monday. She said the information, which showed that the JFC budget spends $88 million more than Gov. Jim Doyle’s budget, and spends $787 million beyond state growth, changed her mind.

"It is imperative to note that these figures were unavailable to members of the Joint Finance Committee several weeks ago when we voted at 6:15 in the morning on the budget.

These new figures indicate a level of spending that is obscene that I find totally unacceptable. I cannot support or cast a final vote for a budget with this outrageous rate of spending."

See Lazich's message: http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=39758

Several Republicans were wondering how Lazich, a vice chair of the Finance Committee, could vote for the budget a few weeks ago, then change her mind when it comes time to vote in the Senate.

“How can you vote for a budget in finance that you had a large part in crafting as vice-chair of the committee, and two weeks later come out and say 'I'm against it,'” wondered one Republican observer, who feels Lazich ambushed both the Senate leadership and Assembly Speaker John Gard with the release. The observer points out that the largest portion of GPR increase over the governor's proposal occurs in medical assistance, a piece of the budget Lazich took the lead in putting together for the caucus.

Senate Dems 'Rock Solid' in Opposition to Budget

With the Republican Senate caucus in flux, Senate Minority Leader Judy Robson held a press conference today to show her caucus is unified in voting against the budget bill passed by the Joint Finance Committee and Assembly. "Rock solid. The Senate Democrats are rock solid," said the Beloit Democrat this morning at a news conference in the Senate Parlor.

Robson accused the Republicans of hiding. "Where are the Republicans? The time is ticking," she said, flanked by Dem Sens. Robert Jauch, Tim Carpenter, Russ Decker, Julie Lassa, Lena Taylor and Bob Wirch. "Maybe they're embarassed by their budget and have to work behind closed doors."

The Democrats hammered the Republicans on property taxes, promising to offer the Dem HOPE tax cut plan as an amendment, and on education spending, prenatal health care and recycling.

"We think it's time homeowners get a break instead of all the special interests," said Decker, who also talked about closing the "Las Vegas loophole."

The most inflammatory rhetoric came from Jauch, who called the Republican education plan "Draconian, and an "execution order on our children. "It is a cynical political ploy to propose the plan. It is a pathetic display of either their ignorance or insensitivity that they fail to recognize the harmful consequences of their action," Jauch said.

The Senate Dems caucused this afternoon beginning at 1:30 p.m. to draw up amendments. Robson said the amendments will be bundled into seven packages including education, health care and property tax relief. Robson and Jauch also said that if there aren't significant changes to the budget, they would recommend that Gov. Jim Doyle veto the entire package.

The Dems also claimed Republicans have been offering them pork in exchange for a "yes" vote on the budget. Robson declined to go into details, but said, "We're not going to trade a bridge for a baby or a school kid."

"You're not going to buy us out. This isn't an auction," said Jauch.

The Dems also lamented the end of the days when "Elroy common sense" would help bring compromise. "The Republican Party has moved a hard turn to the right since (former GOP Gov.) Tommy (Thompson) left for Washington," said Wirch. "They've purged the moderates. We look back with fondness to the compromises we had when Tommy was in the building."

See a press release from the Dems: http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=39747

Monday, June 27, 2005

LFB Analysis Details Assembly Modifications to Budget

The Legislative Fiscal Bureau has put out a document analyzing the changes the state Assembly made to the state budget bill, AB 101. The Assembly passed the bill during an all-night session last Tuesday.

Senate Republicans will caucus tomorrow to try to iron out difference among the members on the budget. The Republicans have a 19-14 edge in the Senate, but two GOP senators, Mike Ellis and Robert Cowles, have already indicated they intend to vote against the budget. Seventeen yes votes will be needed in the Senate to pass the bill and send it to Gov. Jim Doyle.

LFB comparative document

Wednesday, June 22, 2005

Bill Gets Through Assembly

The budget bill, AB 100, passes through the Assembly on a 56-40 vote. Four Republicans voted against the package, Reps. Robin Kreibich, Frank Lasee, Steve Nass and Leah Vukmir.

Gearing Up for Election Year

The Assembly Republicans are doing their best to paint Doyle as a bad budgeter. In his closing remarks, Assembly Speaker John Gard says votes in Joint Finance and motions here tonight by Democrats show "a bipartisan rejection of Gov. Doyle's budget." JFC co-chair Dean Kaufert says it's very telling that more than half the votes in the committee were either 16-0 or 15-1.

Substitute Amendment Approved

The substitute amendment, ASA 1, is passed 59-37. Next is a vote on the budget bill, AB 100, as amended.

Sneak Attack

The night seemed just about over after the Assembly voted to adopt AA 40, Speaker John Gard's amendment to clean up technical aspects of the budget bill. Then a barrage of Democratic amendments poured in. Republicans are not happy.

Dems Finally Get One

In an act of bipartisanship, the GOP-dominated Assembly adopted one of the Democratic budget amendments. The amendment, authored by Rep. Jon Richards, expedites the phase-in for the Social Security tax cut to take effect in three years instead of five. The fiscal impact will be $4 million less in revenues over the biennium. The amendment passed unanimously.

Kreuser: GOP Political Agendas Are Blatant

Toward the end of a very long night, Rep. Jim Kreuser says during a break that the Republican budget is constructed with two goals in mind; the governor's office and the 8th Congressional District.

"The political agendas are pretty blatant," says the Assembly's minority leader. "It's to help their speaker and the congressman in Green Bay, and to put our governor in a certain position.

"I don't think the people of Wisconsin win with that, and surely the children don't."

Assembly Speaker John Gard has formed an exploratory committee to study a run for the 8th Congressional seat currently occupied by U.S. Rep. Mark Green, who is in the primary to run against Dem incumbent Gov. Jim Doyle.

Kreuser admitted it was frustrating to go through an all-night session, after days of meeting to put counter measures to Republican proposals together, only to have all but one of the amendments tabled.

"They were reasonable amendments; they were not off-the-wall amendments," he says.

"It's too bad they're still living in a dream and the people who have to live with a nightmare are going to be the children," Kreuser says. "But we'll see what happens. The Senate has to put the votes together ye."

Recess

The Assembly stands in recess for a brief Rules Committee meeting, (to set the calendar for Thursday), and a Republican caucus. "Five minutes," promised Assembly Majority Leader Michael Huebsch.

The Democrats will not caucus.

Action Winding Down

The amendment votes are going by more quickly now as members on both sides seem to be running out of steam. Four different Dem proposals have gone by the wayside in the last few minutes.

Photo ID Vote Postponed?

Sources on both sides of aisle are saying that the photo ID voter bill will likely be shelved for the night. A Republican source says the vote will be postponed until Thursday because of the late hour.

Deliberations Resume

The Assembly's back in session and there's a sense the session is nearing an end. But the specter of the photo ID voter bill looms at the end of the budget deliberations.

Budget Meeting Turns in to Real Snooze-fest

The Assembly's now been informal for nearly half an hour. There are still at least nine more amendments to be dealt with. There are a couple of lawmakers who take advantage of situation by grabbing a little shut-eye right here in their chairs.

Grothman Pulls Another All-Nighter to Cram for the Budget

GOP Sen. Glenn Grothman, who isn't on the Joint Finance Committee but stayed at the final budget session of the panel all night to educate himself on the document, is doing the same tonight. He can be seen at the east end of the room mostly, peppering the Legislative Fiscal Bureau crew with questions.

A couple times tonight, when the body's been informal, Speaker John Gard has sought Grothman out to get his input on the proceedings. Grothman, a former Assemblyman, has been rumored as considering a vote against the budget in the Senate, a dangerous proposition for the Republicans who have already lost two Senate caucus votes. The budget won't pass with three "no" votes in the Senate.

Asked whether Grothman's being included in the GOP jam sessions to make him feel more comfortable, one staffer said "Sure." Then added, "At least one senator's here tonight. I mean, we're only passing the budget." For the record, Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz was also spotted in the chamber earlier tonight.

Funny Man Mark Pocan

It's late. Nobody's too sharp right now. Some of the lawmakers even seem to be nodding off between votes.

But Dem Rep. Mark Pocan is always good for a chuckle. "This is the amendment that changes the name of the city of Madison to the city of Reagan," he said, standing to introduce his AA 27, which would give preference for state contracts to domestic corporations.

Pocan went through his spiel, observing the time limit imposed by the speaker. But when Rep. Sondy Pope-Roberts asked Pocan had any personal stories that led him to create the amendment, he had an opening.

"Well thank you for asking me that question. That gets me out of the two-minute limit," Pocan said. Pocan went on to tell about being routed from India to Canada to Kansas while trying to get information about his credit card account. The process so bothered him that he paid off the balance and cancelled the card.

Inevitably, the amendment was tabled.

Smart Growth Still Out

Democratic Rep. Spencer Black's AA 24, a proposal to put the Smart Growth program back in the budget, met the same fate as every other Dem amendment tonight: It was tabled.

"I think people were quite surprised that the Joint Finance Committee eliminated a program that's worked very well in our state," Black said.

Republican Rep. Mary Williams summed up the feeling of the GOP members: "Folks in my district do planning on their own, they don't need a law in place."

Tabled

The Assembly is now onto voting on individual legislators' amendments, with the same results - tabled. Be that as it may, it seems like progress and its the first sign this session may end before the sun comes up.

Session Rolls On

The Assembly is up to AA 16, which would restore Gov. Doyle's early release prison program. So far every amendment that has come to a vote has been tabled.

You can check out the text for the amendments and the votes by clicking here.

UW System Revisions Sought

We're up to AA 11 now, a package to revise the budget for the UW System. So far each and every amendment offered by the Democrats have been tabled on a 60-36 partisan vote.

A Republican aide tells me that the Democrats' sum total on the amendments is over $1 billion in spending tonight, but the Dems point out they haven't spent a dime because none of them have passed.

Rep. Dean Kaufert, the Joint Finance Committee co-chair, said he's amazed that the key words in the Democratic proposals are "restore, increase and provide." He said the committee worked hard to reduce the structural deficit, and the Democrats' proposal would undo that.

"I don't know what the heck all these amendments are, but we're going the wrong way," he said.

But Dem Rep. Gary Sherman asked Kaufert, "How many amendments have we passed?"

"You haven't passed any so far," Kaufert said, angry. "But you know what? We're not playing around. This is a $54 billion document, and people in the state expect us to do something and not pee away all the money."

"We haven't spent any money. We haven't busted any budgets," Sherman replied. "I don't think these tantrums make sense at all."

Tuesday, June 21, 2005

Dems Offer Mammoth Health Care Amendment

The minority party Democrats continue to offer package amendments to the Joint Finance budget bill. The latest, AA 9, is a 45-page amendment to alter the health care proposal put together by the Republicans.

See all the amendments by hitting this link, then scanning the left-hand side of the page.

Rep. Kitty Rhoades, who spearheaded the Assembly effort on medical assistance in the JFC, said the Republican version goes far beyond Gov. Jim Doyle's MA plan.

"I'm not much for partisan flame-throwing," Rhoades began. "But we have said from day one this is a budget about priorities. And Gov. Doyle's proposal was a sad statement where medical assistance falls in his priorities."

Rhoades pointed out that the amendment includes language that would transfer money from the Patients Compensation Fund. At first the Dems didn't believe it, until Rhoades read it aloud to them. Then the amendment was withdrawn and sent back to the author.

Deliberations Getting Testy

The edgy feel of the proceedings continues. Dem Rep. Marlin Schneider, a notorious Republican-baiter, took the floor to poke at Republicans for asking questions about the amendments.

He said the Democrats have been trying all session to get information about bills from the Republicans, but are "stone-walled." Schneider continued to goad the majority until one of them yelled, "Sit down."

"You really don't like it when the hypocrisy is pointed out, do you?" he asked. "'Just sit down and shut up.' You said it, not me."

Schneider's broadside continued for several minutes, as he name-checked everyone from Warren Buffett to Thomas Jefferson.

Dem Rep. Gary Hebl called for some decorum, saying to deal with the budget in this fashion was a disservice to taxpayers. "We really need to deal with this in our best mental ability, and we're not doing that right now," he said.

Fiery Gard Asks for Patience

As the body was about to vote on tabling AA 6 regarding funding for school choice programs, Speaker John Gard stepped to the floor microphone to speak to the amendment. At the same time, Speaker Pro Tempore Stephen Freese, who has been running the meetings from the podium all night, called roll.

Gard's temper flared as he threw his black pen to the ground. "Dammit, I told you to slow down," Gard said under his breath as he stalked out of the room.

"What, we're in the middle of a roll call!" shouted a Dem.

At first there was a call for a caucus, but Freese called the meeting informal.

Republican leaders huddled for several minutes to soothe nerves and get everything sorted. After 5-10 minutes, the vote to table was taken and passed.

Then a more composed Gard spoke. "I need to quickly understand all the pieces because these are in packages," Gard said.

He said the AA 6 was written as to fund the program with no state school aids, unlike the governor's. "The way the Democratic amendment was offered, it all came out of property taxes," he said. Gard urged to everyone to have patience as they wade through the amendments.

Assembly Back in Business

The "brief" Dem caucus ended up lasting nearly an hour and a half. The Democrats will come back with a few more K-12 funding amendments, then move to university funding, according to a source.

Schultz Pays a Visit

Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz has dropped by to chat up a few of the Republican Assembly members during the break for a Dem caucus. "I'm having so much fun I don't want to go home," said Schultz, though not quite convincingly.

Sen. Glenn Grothman has also been hanging around the proceedings.

Down Time

As the Democrats plan the next phase of their strategy, the Republicans are kicking back. Some are talking on their cell phones, stretching their legs, or conversing with colleagues. Rep. Stephen Freese is watching a movie, "Texas Rangers," on his laptop computer, which is equipped with a DVD player. Rep. Al Ott is plopped down next to him.

"It's an historical document, how the Texas Rangers came to be," said Freese. (FYI, it's a western about Texas lawmen, not the baseball team formerly owned by President George W. Bush.)

Dems Head Back to Caucus

With amendments slowly dribbling out, Assembly Democrats have asked for a "brief" partisan caucus. GOP members will not caucus.

Settling in to a Pattern

As expected of a minority party, the Democrats are dominating the debate at tonight's budget session. If you can call it a debate. Normally, it takes two sides to debate.

The GOP members sit staring at their laptops. I wonder if they have solitaire? Meantime, the Dems stand and fight for their amendments, usually surpassing the allotted two minutes Speaker Pro Tempore Stephen Freese has allowed for each speaker.

For the most part, the Republicans seem content to allow the Democrats to let out their wind, knowing that in the end the majority will rule the day. Occasionally, Rep. Dean Kaufert, co-chair of the Joint Finance Committee, or JFC member Rep. Scott Jensen or Assembly Majority Leader Michael Huebsch will stand to defend the Republican budget plan. But mostly it's the Dems talking.

Set 'em Up, Knock 'em Down

The Democrats continue to bring their amendments to the floor and the Republicans continue to table them. The latest, AA 5, is to restore funds to the SAGE program, public school breakfast program and four-year-old kindergarten.

Amendments are appearing slowly on the Assembly in-session page. You can see the page here. Links to the amendments are in the box on the left-hand side of the page.

Schmiedicke Letter

Below is a letter from state budget director David Schmiedicke to Administration Secretary Marc Marotta. Dems have been reading from it to make their case for why the JFC's $458 million increase in school funding is actually a cut.

Date: June 21, 2005

To: Marc Marotta, Secretary

From: David Schmiedicke, State Budget Director

Subject: School District Revenue Limits -- REVISED

We have received a number of inquiries regarding the impact of the reduction to the allowable per pupil revenue limit increase made by the Joint Committee on Finance (JCF') in its version of the 2005-07 biennial budget bill (AB 100).

As you know, Governor Doyle's budget recommendations retained the current law allowable increase, which is last year's allowable increase plus increase in the consumer price index. Under current law, the increases are estimated to be $248.48 per pupil in FY2005-06 and $252 in FY2006-07. The JCF version of the budget reduces those increases to $120 per pupil in FY06 and $100 in FY2006-07.

For the biennium, this represents a reduction of an estimated $352 million in school district revenues compared to current law. On a percentage basis, current law and the Governor's proposal would provide the average district with per pupil revenue increases of approximately 2.9% in each year (over the state average base revenue per pupil of $8,415 for FY05). Under the JCF version of the budget, the allowable increase would be reduced to 1.4% in FY06 and 1.2% in FY07.

The net increase in school district revenue limits after the JCFreductions to current law can also be compared with the increase in theall-funds state budget adopted by JCF. Compared with the fiscal year2004-05 base of $24.9 billion, the JCF budget increases all funds spending over the prior year by 5.0% in fiscal year 2005-06 and 2.4% infiscal year 2006-07. The increase to general fund spending in the JCF budget over the fiscal year 2004-05 base of $12.0 billion is 7.7% infiscal year 2005-06 and 2.6% in fiscal year 2006-07 over the prior year.

HOPE Plan, Tuition Cap Amendments Tabled

About an hour and 45 minutes into the session, the first actions are taken as AA 1 and AA 2 are tabled.

H-E-Double-Hockey-Sticks

Dem Rep. Frank Boyle wound up a long, fiery oratory on the dangers of the Republican education budget by saying the state's schools are in danger of going to hell.

Speaker Pro Tempore Stephen Freese reminded the Superior Democrat and rest of the body to be cautious in their use of language.

"Mr. Speaker, what bothered you? Hell? Did hell bother you?" Boyle shouted back.

"Just let's keep some of the intensity down and just think about the minors who may be listening," Freese replied.

Dems' HOPE Plan Dominates Discussion

Dems continue to try to sell their HOPE tax relief plan. The 10 minute debate on tabling the amendment has now stretched to nearly an hour.

The Democrats say the plan will close corporate loopholes, and the Republicans are responding that those new corporate taxes will come back to bite consumers and rank-and-file taxpayers. Republicans say the HOPE plan would increase taxes on items like diapers and wheelchairs, which the Democrats deny and call "scare tactics."

Though the debate stretches on, GOP Rep. Mark Gundrum has his humor intact. "Whatever spending increases the other side proposes tonight, please don't propose a tax increase on diapers," said the father of five. He and his wife Mary's latest was born in February.

Happy Anniversary Rep. Rhoades

Some of us in this room have much better things to do, like Rep. Kitty Rhoades. She's celebrating her wedding anniversary with an all-night budget session. Rhoades, whose husband is in the gallery tonight, remarked on the weird turns life can take.

"Thirty years ago, I never would have believed I'd be spending my 30th anniversary here," she said.

Amendments Coming In

The session begins with an from GOP Rep. Frank Lasee, who proposes to cap tuition increases at state universities to 3 percent.

The second amendment offered is the Assembly Dems HOPE property tax relief proposal.

There are motions on the floor to table both amendments, but discussion continues.

You can keep up with the amendments by clicking on the link below.

Assembly in-session page

Let the Games Begin

At 6:30, Speaker John Gard calls the Assembly to session and Rep. Dan Vrakas asked for a quorum call. There are only a couple Democrats and about half the Republicans in the chamber as Chief Clerk Pat Fuller begins to read the list of names, but a quorum's worth scurries in as Fuller runs down the roll.

A Little More Time for Dems

Assembly Chief Clerk Pat Fuller has just announced the Assembly will convene at 6:30.

Assembly Still Stands Informal

Many of the Republican Assembly members are at their seats and ready to go, including Speaker John Gard and Majority Leader Michael Huebsch, but no Democrats are present in the chamber. A very long night is expected, likely an all-nighter like the last Joint Finance session.

Caucus Time

The Assembly has adjourned to go into partisan caucus. Expect a lengthy break as the Legislative Reference Bureau toils to draft Democratic amendments.

Before Break, Kreuser Laments Budget "Distractions"

Assembly Minority Leader Jim Kreuser knocked Assembly Republicans for trying to "intertwine" non-fiscal bills with budget deliberations. He said including the photo ID voter bill, Fair Claims and cloning bills on the agenda this week is meant to be a distraction from the priority at hand.

"It's stirring up controversy to keep everyone scurrying around here when the budget is supposed to be the number one thing," he said.

Assembly Speaker John Gard took exception to the accusation, saying there are limited days left in the spring session. "Before we leave for July we're going to pass some other bills, too," he said.

Gard lauded the Joint Finance Committee's budget work, saying the revised bill stops Gov. Jim Doyle's fund raids and cuts taxes on gas and Social Security. But he said the cornerstone is the property tax freeze.

Assembly's Budget Day Begins

Assembly Chief Clerk Pat Fuller called roll at about 11:05 as members began to file in. There is a sparse crowd of spectators in the gallery.

Assembly To Vote On Budget Today

-- The Assembly is scheduled to meet at 11 a.m. today to begin voting on the budget. Insiders expect a long and grueling day, with upwards of 150 amendments by Democrats, although they say the number could shrink with withdrawals and redundancies, and other hot-button bills that could complicate the process.

Two Assembly Republicans, Steve Nass and Frank Lasee, released statements saying they will not vote for the JFC budget.

*See Nass' release
*See Lasee's release

The Senate plans to take up the budget bill next week on Wednesday and/or Thursday, according to Majority Leader Dale Schultz's office.

See the Assembly calendar

Monday, June 20, 2005

LFB Analysis Comparing Doyle, JFC Budgets Released.

The Legislative Fiscal Bureau released a detailed analysis sizing up Gov. Jim Doyle's budget against the revisions made by the Joint Finance Committee.

LFB Analysis

Tuesday, June 14, 2005

Disappointed Cowles Speaks Out on Budget

Republican Sen. Robert Cowles said the state budget bill passed last week by the Joint Finance Committee contains pork, does little if anything to reduce bonding or truly cut spending, contributes to a structural deficit and seems designed as a challenge to the Wisconsin Education Association Council.

Cowles, of Green Bay, made that stinging assessment Monday in an interview with WisPolitics. He was the only JFC Republican member to vote against the final budget package, saying he rejected it to ensure the two-year spending bill gets a thorough going-over by fellow fiscal conservatives in the Senate Republican caucus.

“I resent the cavalier attitude taken toward the expenditure of state tax money. I voted against this budget,” Cowles told WisPolitics in an interview today. “It still has a substantial structural deficit. The bonding is a little bit less than the governor’s (budget proposal), and that is not saying anything. And there still is a substantial increase in the GPR (general purpose revenues) bond.”

“They got quite a game going on,” Cowles said of his committee colleagues, referring to the major spending motions rushed through during the last budget meeting that ended shortly before 7 a.m. on June 10. “We needed to stop and not be acting in the middle of the night, get all the data and make decisions.”

Cowles said the budget could have been much more frugal, citing in particular the use of a $50 million levy credit in the 2007-09 budget to fund school aids.

“I don’t want to pay for it with stuff in the next budget. That becomes part of the structural deficit. That’s a wing and a prayer... and that’s what got us into the previous ($3.2 billion deficit) mess.”

While Republican legislative leaders were declaring their budget a victory for the taxpayers, Cowles said: “The only substantial cut to the governor’s (budget) was the school aid item.” The committee’s budget contains $458 million more for school aids than current levels, which is about $400 million less than the increase Doyle sought.

Cowles said if the committee could have spread cuts “more proportionately” in more areas and dropped the structural deficit from where it rests, the committee “could have delivered a higher per pupil” spending rate. It would not have reached the level sought by Gov. Jim Doyle, but it would have been higher than the final product, he said. “They (Republicans) didn’t want to confront the different constituents,” Cowles said. “They only wanted to confront just one -- the teachers' lobby.”

Moments before the final vote was to be taken, the committee took a break and Cowles left the room with Republican legislative leadership. “I was under enormous pressure,” according to Cowles, saying it was possibly the most partisan pressure he’s ever felt. He said he was being urged by majority Republican members to “just go along with it.”

But Cowles was having none of it, and joined the committee’s four Democratic members in opposition. “I wasn’t just going to suck this in,” he said.

“If I voted yes, that would have been the end of it. The budget would have had no substantial discussion in our caucus,” he said. “This way, the fiscal conservatives will have another opportunity.”

Fiscal Bureau Director Bob Lang told WisPolitics.com the agency’s final analysis and documents detailing the Finance Committee’s budget bill should be done in several days. The budget bill first goes to the Assembly, where it is expected to pass, likely on a party line vote.

That may not be the case in the Senate, where Cowles says his concerns may be shared by at least three other Republicans -- Mike Ellis of Neenah, Glenn Grothman of West Bend and Tom Reynolds of West Allis. Republicans control the Senate, 19-14. And the four fiscal conservatives could have an impact on how the budget advances.

-- by Joanne Haas

Monday, June 13, 2005

Reaction to JFC's Budget Passage

See a sampling of press releases on the JFC's budget passage.

MONDAY, JUNE 13

-- Sen. Kanavas: Lauds Funding of Zoo Interchange Study in Budget
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38672

-- Rep. Honadel: Statement on Gov. Doyle's Visit to South Milwaukee
High School
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38676

FRIDAY, JUNE 10

-- Elderly and Disabled Transportation Coalition: Governor and
Legislature Prioritize Transportation for the Elderly and People with
Disabilities
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38595

-- Fyrst Campaign: GOP Property Tax Freeze is a Trunk Full of Junk
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38570

-- Gov. Doyle: To Join Southeast Wisconsin Superintendents and School
Board Members in Opposing Republican Education Cuts
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38613

-- Madison Mayor Cieslewicz: State Budjet Mixed Bag for Madison
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38610

-- Pharmacy Society of Wisconsin: JFC Restores Critical Pharmacy Funding
http://www.wispolitics.com/1006/061005pharm.pdf

-- Project ABC: K-12 Education Budget is Terrible Policy for Children and Taxpayers
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38622

-- Rep. Hahn: Finance Committee Adopts Hahn’s Health Insurance Tax Cut
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38594

-- Rep. Huebsch: Doyle Needs a Calculator
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38597

-- Rep. Kreuser: Statement on the GOP's Raid on Education
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38596

-- Rep. Richards: Statement on GOP Cuts to Milwaukee Public Schools
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38608

-- Rep. Sherman: Asks Governor to Veto Entire Budget
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38615

-- Rep. Towns: Budget Reflections
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38618

-- Reps. Grigsby, Sinicki: Condemn Republican Cuts to Quality Control of Day Care
http://www.wispolitics.com/1006/sinicki.pdf

-- Sen. Breske: Appalled by Republican "Slash and Burn" Tactics on School Aids
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38592

-- Sen. Kedzie: New Budget Cuts Taxes While Looking out for State’s Most Vulnerable Citizens
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38612

-- Sen. Lazich: Votes to Cease Picking the Pockets of Wisconsin’s Residents
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38582

-- Sen. Leibham: Budget Puts Taxpayers First
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38571

-- Sierra Club: Budget Actions De-Rail Popular Hiawatha Amtrak Service
http://www.wispolitics.com/1006/050610jfc.pdf

-- State Superintendent Burmaster: Statement on Budget Actions of the JCF
http://www.wispolitics.com/1006/6_10_05Statement.pdf

-- TDA: JFC Plan Keeps Wisconsin Moving
http://pressrelease.tdawisconsin.org/

-- TRUST Coalition: Transportation Package Will Keep State’s Economy on Right Track
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38579

-- U.S. Rep. Green: Statement on Inclusion of Funds in State Budget for Sturgeon Bay Bridge Project
http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38624

Friday, June 10, 2005

Newspapers Cover Budget's End

Here's a round-up of budget news stories from today's papers:

Final Vote Tallied

-- At about 6:15 a.m., following an all-night meeting, the Joint Finance Committee completed its last roll call vote on the 2005-07 biennial state budget, voting 11-5 to approve the wrap-up motion, appropriately titled "Motion 2005."

Sen. Robert Cowles was the only Republican to vote against the budget.

"We did it through dialogue, we did it through compromise," said Rep. Dean Kaufert, co-chair of the committee along with Sen. Scott Fitzgerald.

"The process went well, and I think that sometimes that's as important as the final product," Fitzgerald said.

On Thursday, Assembly Speaker John Gard said he expects the Assembly to take up the budget on June 22, and deliver it to Gov. Jim Doyle by July 1.

Funny Time for a Coffee Break

The committee has come to a vote on the final wrap-up motion, the climactic moment of the JFC budget process, and Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald called a time out just before roll call. He and Co-Chair Dean Kaufert have disappeared into the wings of the hearing room.

LFB Director Bob Lang joined the chairs in back, then came back out and huddled with his staff.

Rumor is the Senate Republicans are doing a head count to see where caucus members stand on the final vote.

The break lasts nearly an hour.

Lazich Snubbed By Assembly Republicans

Sen. Mary Lazich took exception to Assembly Republicans voting against a motion she introduced just before adjournment. She introduced it, she said, to correct an inconsistency in the statutes in charge for copies between the clerk of courts, who are authorized to charge $1.25, and the register in probate, who are authorized to charge $1.

The innocuous motion failed 7-9, with five of the Assembly Republicans joining the four Dems on the committee. Only Rep. Scott Jensen voted with Lazich.

"That is as low as it gets," Lazich said, standing. "I'm going to walk out."

JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald tried to diffuse the situation with humor. "We've got one more vote left," he said laughing.

Fitzgerald then asked to have the record expunged of the previous vote so the committee could take another. Second time around it passed 11-5.

General Fund Tax Proposal Passes As Dawn Breaks at Capitol

The sun is rising, a fine time to pass an omnibus motion on general fund taxes, which is what the Joint Committee on Finance did on a 12-4 vote. The Republican proposal for general fund taxes increases decreases general fund revenue by $12.3 million over the biennium compared to Gov. Doyle's budget bill.

Still Here

Yes, the Joint Finance Committee is still in session. Members are currently trying to wrap their minds around an 8-page motion from Rep. Scott Jensen on utility aid payments. It passes 12-4.

GOP Property Tax Freeze Approved

Not surprisingly, the JFC approved the Republican property tax freeze plan 12-4 on a party-line vote. The freeze has been passed twice already, and vetoed each time by Gov. Jim Doyle.

GOP Categorical Aids Package Gets Green Light

The categorical aids package put together by Republican members passed on a party-line 12-4 vote. The biggest piece of the package is a $38 million reduction in SAGE funding over the biennium compared to Gov. Doyle's budget proposal.

DPI General School Aids and Revenue Limits Passed

The JFC passed by an 11-5 margin a general school aids and revenue limits motion. According to the Legislative Fiscal Bureau, the motion is a reduction from the Doyle budget bill of $337 million in GPR.

Sen. Robert Cowles was the only Republican to join the four Democrats in voting against the motion.

Sen. Taylor: Designated Filibusterer

It's become apparent, especially over the last couple days, that Sen. Lena Taylor is the Democrats designated filibusterer on the Joint Finance Committee.

The committee has been on the DPI budget since about 1:15 a.m., and members have taken the floor to espouse or shred the Republican proposal for K-12 funding. But Taylor, as she did last night in the debate over a motion regarding family planning and earlier tonight on a motion to fund the Bishop's Creek Cultural Center, has taken over the debate. She read alphabetically through the list of school districts that will lose money under the Republican plan, weaving in anecdotes and insults for at least half an hour.

Rep. Dan Meyer was able to get a few words in, asking Taylor about the districts she didn't mention who were losing only nominal amounts. But she took the floor back and kept it for another 10 minutes strong.

List Taylor read from

DPI Budget Before the Committee

As the Republican-controlled JFC turned its attention to the K-12 funding bill it's put together, Dem Sen. Lena Taylor took the opportunity to mention some special guests in the gallery: the Milwaukee Public Schools superintendent and six members of the Milwaukee School Board.

Dem Rep. Pedro Colon wished them luck. "Under this proposal, Milwaukee Public Schools are being cut $40 million," he said. "The fact is that you're not going to be able to fund anything."

Kaufert Lets Go of Fair Claims

Coming back into session, JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert said he won't draft a motion to include Fair Claims into the budget.

"There is an issue hanging out there for some time now. We've been looking for ways to resolve this, and we're not there and we're almost to the finish line here," he said. He said the cleanup of the Fox River is the most important economic and employment issue in his district, and it would have an impact of hundreds of millions of dollars on the paper industry.

"I believe that we've got to come to some resolution to get that river cleaned up," he said.

But, he said, he's received assurances from Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz that the legislation will get a fair shake in the Senate. "I feel pretty good I'm going to get a fair fight, and I've been assured I'm going to get that hearing and get vote in the committee."

Some Transpo Fund Items Not Found in the Governor's Version of the Bill

Courtesy of a budget observe, and since I've got the time, here's a list of some expenditures that found their way into the Transpo Fund after the Gov. Doyle passed it to JFC:

- $1.6 million in the Harbor Assistance for dockwall construction in Marinette for the Waupaca Foundry

- $500,000 in enhancements for Eisner Ave.in Sheboygan County

- $80,000 in enhancements for Village of Oregon streetscaping

- $480,000 in enhancements for STH 29 bicycle and pedestrian bridge in Weston

- Underpass of STH 69 for the Sugar River State Trail in New Glarus

- Conduct a safety study of STH 59 in Sauk County

- $38 million for preliminary engineering for the Zoo Interchange/US 45 reconstruction project

- Guidance signs for Our Lady of Guadalupe Shrine in La Crosse County, for Wayland Academy in Dodge County, and the Waukesha County Historical Museum

- $500,000 increase for the Milwaukee County Expressway Policing Aids

Fair Claims Rears Its Head

The committee has taken a 20 minute break to allow Co-Chair Dean Kaufert time to discuss a possible motion with his caucus, and a source says its to talk about Fair Claims legislation. Kaufert is the Assembly author of so-called Fair Claims legislation that moves onus of litigation on the Fox River PCB cleanup from the paper companies to their insurers, and there has been talk of its inclusion in the budget bill for weeks now. Kaufert has always insisted he's keeping his options open.

The chamber is filled with lobbyists working for paper and insurance companies, and leadership from both caucuses have been coming in and out all night for words with committee members.

Two Jensen Motions, Two Opposite Results

The committee approved a motion authored by Rep. Scott Jensen that requires the proceeds from the sale of any state properties in the biennium that exceed $36 million to be put in the budget stabilization fund. The motion passed 16-0.

A second motion from Jensen was not as successful. It required the Department of Administration to either sell each state-owned power plant or wastewater treatment facility or contract with a private entity for its operation by April 1, 2007. If sold, the proceeds would go to the budget stabilization fund. It failed 8-8.

Thursday, June 09, 2005

Committee Approves Expansion of Gaming

The committee has given thumbs-up to a Sen. Russ Decker-authored motion to allow betting via video gaming devices that display dog or horse races previously run at another race track.

The motion authorizes licensees of parimutel wagering to operate the games. It was passed 9-7.

Taylor Takes Her Time

Sen. Lena Taylor is trying to get a motion to enumerate the construction of the $10 million Bishop's Creek Cultural Center in the City of Milwaukee, and has been filibustering and asking questions of the Legislative Fiscal Bureau for the last half hour. Meanwhile, committee members of both parties are getting up, stretching their legs, and generally ignoring the discussion, and folks in the gallery appear to be growing very restless.

The Taylor motion would add $2.8 million in bonding revenue to the state Building Program.

Sen. Alberta Darling and Rep. Scott Jensen have a different motion with a different take on funding the project: to make a grant of $375,000 in each year of the biennium from the Minority Business Finance Program to the Bishop's Creek project.

Taylor's motion failed 2-14, with Rep. Pedro Colon Taylor's only ally. Darling's motion passed 12-4.

When the committee was finally ready to take the vote, the committee clerk was nowhere to be found. Apparently she'd ducked out to use the restroom, but returned momentarily to reclaim her seat and call the roll.

Transpo Motion Passed

The Republican Transpo/Commerce omnibus motion passed 11-5 through the Joint Finance Committee. Sen. Robert Cowles was the only Republican member to vote against it.

The committee will move next to some of the minor items left on the agenda, bypassing K-12 funding for the time being.

Transpo Still the Topic

The JFC is still considering motions to amend the Republican Transportation/Commerce omnibus motion. Like last night, the hearing room is surprising full for the late hour.

At Last

Meeting is called to order. Never thought I'd be so happy to hear a roll call.

The first order of business is the Transportation-Commerce package.

Could It Be?

It's the first serious sign that this meeting may actually start. JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald has announced the meeting will begin in 10 minutes. Hallelujah.

Vehicle Registration Fee Hike Ditched

Republicans plan to nix Gov. Doyle's planned $10 increase in vehicle registration fees and $16.50 increase for light truck registration fees. Cutting the increase from the budget will decrease transportation fund revenues by an estimated $23 million in 2005-06 and $47 million in 2006-07.

Budget paper 718

GOP Proposal Takes a Chunk Out of SAGE

The Republican proposal that will be introduced in Joint Finance tonight eliminates most of the funding increase for the Student Achievement Guarantee in Education program. (Budget Paper 605).
The budget motion crafted by GOP legislators deletes $12 million for SAGE in 2005-06 and $24.5 million in 2006-07. That leaves an increase of $2.5 million in 2005-06 and $3.5 million in 2006-07 for the SAGE program.

The SAGE cut is the major piece of the Republicans plan to cut $50 million from categorical school aids over the next biennium.

Blogger Fairness Moment

Having alerted you many times to the late starts of the Joint Finance Committee, this blogger would be remiss if I didn't say that Gov. Jim Doyle's press conference today regarding the GOP education proposal started 20 minutes late.

(Of course, that pales compared to the 8-plus hour late start of the JFC today.)

Doyle Rips GOP K-12 Budget

In a press conference this afternoon, Gov. Jim Doyle lambasted the Republican education funding proposal that will be brought to the Joint Finance Committee tonight.

"The Republican budget proposal announced today would cut Wisconsin's schools by over $400 million - the largest education cut in decades," he said. "Their proposal would force school districts to choose between a massive property tax increase or laying off thousands of teachers, raising class sizes, and cutting programs from music to athletics."

Doyle statement

Standing behind Doyle were the four Democratic members of the JFC and other Democratic legislators. Also dropping by to check out the press conference were JFC Co-Chairs Dean Kaufert and Scott Fitzgerald, and JFC members Reps. Jeff Stone and Scott Jensen.

Responding to Fitzgerald's statement earlier today that, "Anyone who says this budget cuts education funding is lying, plain and simple," Doyle said that the Republican proposal "isn't even keeping up with current law."

The governor said the Republican plan "is the result of a secret budget process that put education last."

Asked what pieces of the budget he may veto, or if he'll veto the entire bill altogether, Doyle replied, "I'm going to keep all my options open and I'm going to look at everything."

"I'll look to see what I can do with the use of the partial veto," Doyle said. "But in the end if I have to veto the whole budget to put property taxpayers and education first in this state, that's what I'll do."

JFC Holds Off On Meeting Until 6:30 p.m.

The final pieces of the budget have been announced, but committee chairs have said the JFC won't meet until at least 6:30 p.m. to allow committee members and observers to get dinner before what could turn into a marathon session.

GOP Announces Final Pieces of Budget Agreement

Although drafting motions for tonight's Joint Finance session isn't even finished, GOP leaders, JFC members and other Republican legislators gathered in the Senate Parlor to take a victory lap on their overhauled budget bill and jab at Gov. Jim Doyle.

The Republicans unveiled the final pieces of their biennial budget, which includes replacing Doyle's property tax freeze plan with their Legislature-approved version, a $458 million increase in K-12 funding (compared to Doyle's $855 million proposal), a one-cent cut in the gas tax, and a cut to the Social Security tax.

Assembly Speaker John Gard said the Republican-derived budget, "puts Wisconsin in a great direction for future job growth," and blasted Doyle's budget bill as offering, "phony money, empty promises and skyrocketing debt."

"This is an honest budget," Gard said. "It fulfills the promises we made last fall, and strengthens our economic future."

In an afternoon press conference, Doyle said the Republican budget is "the largest cut to education in decades."

Their proposal, he said, would force districts to choose between a massive property tax increase, laying off teachers or raising class sizes.

Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz said the GOP budget "recognizes Wisconsin's finest and most important asset is our school children." He said the $455 million increase for education is two-and-a-half times more than the increase in last budget, and accounts for a quarter of the new money in the budget. "We're making a historic investment in their future."

Gard said the $455 million amounts to a $120 per pupil increase in 2005-06 and $100 in 2006-07; Doyle had proposed $248 and $252, respectively.

Dem Sen. Robert Jauch called the GOP education proposal "horrific" and "indefensible" in a press release today.

“They are either in complete denial or ignorant of their own actions which will result in a $110 million cut for Wisconsin schools in the next two months alone,” Jauch said. “To somehow suggest that taking that amount of money out of our classrooms is not a cut, is simply absurd.”

See Jauch's release: http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38513

But the Republicans said their increase was done without raiding funds and increasing fees. JFC Co-Chair Sen. Scott Fitzgerald said, "Anyone who says this budget cuts education funding is lying, plain and simple," perhaps a reference to a statement this morning from Doyle. (See the statement)

Fitsgerald touted the committee for reducing the state's debt load, and not raiding funds for GPR dollars. "Republicans know people want action not gimmicks," he said.

JFC Co-Chair Rep. Dean Kaufert said the budget, "offers hope for taxpayers, hope for children, and hope for veterans."

"We did it with real money, and we fixed a lot of holes," he said. "We cut up Jim Doyle's credit card in this budget and we said we're not going to use it anymore."

According to the co-chairs, the Republicans will propose a transfer of $250 million from the Transportation Fund (as opposed to Doyle's proposed $500 million) to fund budget items like school aids and other GPR expenditures.

Fitzgerald and Kaufert are sticking to their timeline of finishing JFC deliberations tonight, although they're still crunching the final numbers. Gard said he expects the Assembly to take up the budget on June 22, and deliver it to Doyle by July 1.

See today's release from legislative leaders and the JFC co-chairs: http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38506

See interviews conducted last week with a selection of JFC members previewing the final deal: http://www.wispolitics.com/index.iml?Article=38489

Watch for more reaction on the WisPolitics Budget Blog and in the right-hand column at www.wispolitics.com

Legislative Leaders Plan 2:30 p.m. Budget Announcement

A notice from Speaker John Gard's office says the legislative leadership has planned a 2:30 p.m. press conference in the Senate Parlor at the Capitol to make a "major budget announcement."

See the media advisory.

Start Time Still Up in the Air

The budget hearing room is still barren. Sources are saying co-chairs Scott Fitzgerald and Dean Kaufert are still crunching numbers with the Legislative Fiscal Bureau, and the meeting will likely not commence until 2:30-3, and will go later than last night's midnight finish. A JFC press conference prior to the meeting is still unconfirmed.

Doyle: Happy with Health Care Package, Worried for Education

Gov. Jim Doyle released a statement this morning on the Joint Finance Committee's health care package.

"I am relieved that the committee abandoned their earlier proposals to cut vital health care programs like BadgerCare and SeniorCare, which provide health care and prescription drug coverage for seniors and working families," he said. "In my budget, I fully protected these important commitments, because now is not the time to back away from the health care needs of our citizens.

"But I remain very concerned that Republicans are poised to adopt the harshest education cuts in memory. This is exactly what I warned against when I introduced my budget in February, but Republicans have not gotten the message."

Doyle statement

Meeting Late to Start (Surprise)

It's noon and the budget hearing room is virtually empty. There's no sign of committee members or their staff, and there's talk the meeting may not commence for until after 1 p.m.

Republican members met this morning to go over the final budget papers and to get last-minute numbers from the Legislative Fiscal Bureau. The offices of co-chairs Scott Fitzgerald and Dean Kaufert are saying a press conference may be held today.

Meeting Late to Start

It's noon and the hearing room is virtually empty. Committee members were meeting this morning to go over the final budget pieces and get some last-minute numbers from the Legislative Fiscal Bureau. According to the offices of JFC co-chairs Dean Kaufert and Scott Fitzgerald, the committee is considering holding a press conference today.

Committee Comes Back at 11 a.m.

The committe adjourned shortly after midnight, and is scheduled to reconvene at 11 a.m.. Senate Republicans will meet at 10 a.m. to go over bills.

Wednesday, June 08, 2005

Lazich Proposes Shifting Family Planning Funding

A late night motion by Sen. Mary Lazich that would shift family planning services funding by giving preference to applicants that are local health departments or tribal health centers.

She said she proposed the change to allows counties to apply for the funds, but does not mandate they take them over. The county can also subcontract with other agencies for the service. "It should give everyone a comfort level that the county provide these services," she said.

The motion affects how the Department of Health and Family Services distributes nearly $2 million in GPR and $1.7 million in federal money.

But the controversial part is a section of the motion that eliminates references in state statutes 253.02 (2m) and 253.07 (1) (a) and (b) to "nondirective information explaining pregnancy termination, and to permit the promotion, encouragement, or counseling in favor of, or referral either directly or through an intermediary for prenatal care and delivery and infant care, foster care, or adoption."

Sen. Lena Taylor and Rep. Mark Pocan launched into long diatribes against the motion.

Pocan said the motion is a thinly disguised attack on Planned Parenthood from anti-abortion forces.

"This is absolutely the most ridiculous motion we have seen yet here," Pocan said.

"This is political pork for the right wing," he said. "This essentially is a gag order for comprehensive family planning services in Wisconsin."
Pocan said the motion is designed to "stop Planned Parenthood and other organizations that provide comprehensive family planning services" and would shut down 53 organizations in this state and jeopardize the health care of 32,000 women.

The committee voted 4-12 to remove the controversial language, and the first part of the motion, giving preference to counties, passed 11-5.

Lazich Proposes Shifting Family Planning Funding

A late night motion by Sen. Mary Lazich that would shift family planning services funding by giving preference to applicants that are local health departments or tribal health centers.

She said she proposed the change to allows counties to apply for the funds, but does not mandate they take them over. The county can also subcontract with other agencies for the service. "It should give everyone a comfort level that the county provide these services," she said.

The motion affects how the Department of Health and Family Services distributes nearly $2 million in GPR and $1.7 million in federal money.

But the controversial part is a section of the motion that eliminates references in state statutes 253.02 (2m) and 253.07 (1) (a) and (b) to "nondirective information explaining pregnancy termination, and to permit the promotion, encouragement, or counseling in favor of, or referral either directly or through an intermediary for prenatal care and delivery and infant care, foster care, or adoption."

Sen. Lena Taylor and Rep. Mark Pocan launched into long diatribes against the motion.

Pocan said the motion is a thinly disguised attack on Planned Parenthood from anti-abortion forces.

"This is absolutely the most ridiculous motion we have seen yet here," Pocan said.

"This is political pork for the right wing," he said. "This essentially is a gag order for comprehensive family planning services in Wisconsin."
Pocan said the motion is designed to "stop Planned Parenthood and other organizations that provide comprehensive family planning services" and would shut down 53 organizations in this state and jeopardize the health care of 32,000 women.

The committee voted 4-12 to remove the controversial language, and the first part of the motion, giving preference to counties, passed 11-5.

MA Omnibus Passes

The omnibus funding motion for medical assistance passed through the Joint Finance Committee on a unanimous vote

Democrats tried, with a breathtaking lack of success, to bring motions to restore specific funding items. But overall, it was hard for them to find much fault with a motion that added $364 million in GPR to MA programs.

"What we did for the state of Wisconsin here is rather phenomenal," said Sen. Mary Lazich, one of the authors of the bill.

"We made a commitment with real money and made sure we didn't cut eligibility - which we didn't," said another co-author of the bill, Rep. Kitty Rhoades.

JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert said while the committee has argued over a lot in the budget, "I think it's pretty clear that we are committed to the MA." Kaufert says in all his years on the committee, he never saw a 16-0 vote on MA.

Cutting into the round of backslapping, Sen. Luther Olsen reminded the committee that the tough votes will come tomorrow.

Committee Back in Session

JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert gaveled the committee back to order and took up budget paper 112. The committee unanimously approved alternatives 2 and 3 under section A, and alternative 1 under section B.

Committee Should Be Back Shortly

Republican members have been back at their positions for about the last 15 minutes, and Dems are also ready to go. The atmosphere is lively, or maybe everyone is just a little giddy.

JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert has announced the meeting will commence in five minutes.

Republicans Keeping Tricks Up Their Sleeves

With a $364 million GPR increase proposed for medical assistance, some are wondering where the Republicans are going to come up with the money. As GOP members have said, there will be reductions to the per pupil school funding increase Gov. Doyle proposed. Doyle's budget contains an increase of $248 in 2005-06, and $252 in 2006-07. Sources familiar with committee negotiations say Republican members are considering an increase of about $120-130 per pupil. They will also be helped along by higher tax re-estimates that were released a few weeks ago.

See previous blog item on revenue re-estimates
One thing the GOP caucus is promising: The budget will balance in the end.

"Today we're making MA a priority, tomorrow we're going to fund it," is all JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert would say of the Republican plans.

Republicans Deliver $365 Million "Spender" for Medical Assistance

Joint Finance Committee Co-Chair Dean Kaufert delivered an omnibus motion on MA to the committee Democrats and press at about 8:30. In all, the net GPR effect is to increase authorized spending in the budget bill by nearly $365 million and to reduce revenue by $27.6 million in the 2005-07 biennium. The overall effect on the general fund is $392.5 million.

Here are some of the highlights:

Nursing Home Rates and Bed Assessment (Budget paper 385) - The motion would delete Gov. Doyle's provisions relating to the bed assessment and nursing home rate increase. This would reduce funding for DHFS by $38 million in 2005-06 and $50.8 million in 2006-07. Also deleted is funding in Doyle's budget bill for the Department of Veteran Affairs to support the governor's proposal to increase the monthly nursing home bed asessment on all licensed beds at the Wisconsin Veterans Homes at King and Union Grove.

Instead, it provides nearly $36 million over the biennium to increase rates for nursing homes by approximately 1.4 percent each year. All revenue from the current bed assessment would be deposited in the MA trust fund.

HMO Assessment and Rate Increase (385)- All the governor's provisions would be deleted. Funding would be reduced by $36 million in 2005-06 and $81 million in 2006-07.

Pharmacy Reimbursement (Budget paper 371)- The motion proposes to delete the Gov. Doyle's plan to reduce the average wholesale price minus 13 percent, to the AWP minus 16 percent, reimbursement to pharmacies for brand name drugs; reduce the dispensing fee from $4.38 to $3.88 per prescription; and eliminate the 5 percent enhancement the state pays to pharmacies for drugs dispensed under SeniorCare. Funding in the bill would be increased nearly $40 million over the biennium.

SeniorCare Program Options (Budget paper 377)- The motion proposes to take no action.

Medicare Break - Take Two

The Joint Finance Committee is taking its second break to finish up and distribute a Medical Assistance package. JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert set a return time for the committee of 7:30.

Doyle Speaks Out on Hmong Cultural Center Vote

Gov. Doyle expressed his disappointment over the Joint Finance Committee's decision to delete funding for the Hmong Cultural Center in a statement. Check it out by clicking the link below:

Doyle statement

Quotable

"People ask me, 'What is the committee going to do next, buy some mercury and order it dumped in the lakes?' I tell them no, I don't see that motion coming," said Rep. Mark Pocan, lamenting some of the votes the committee has taken that he feels will hurt the environment. Pocan was trying to persuade the committee to approve more bonding for the nonpoint water pollution program.

$70.9 Million Saved by Moving the Pea

Gov. Doyle has been criticized by Republicans for budgetary sleight of hand, but the JFC approved a shell game tactic that defers a shared revenue payment until the next biennium. (Budget paper 677).

By unanimous consent, the Governor's recommendation to delay the date for making state aid payments for exempt computers, cash registers, and fax machines from the first Monday in May of each year to the fourth Monday in July of each year, beginning in 2007, was approved. That brings $70.9 million back into this year's GPR.

At least one committee member wanted to take a vote on the issue. "This is shoving the problem into the next budget," said Sen. Robert Cowles. "These are the kind of decisions that have gotten us into touble in the past. Why I don't want to do this things is why I've been such a jerk on spending in the last few weeks."

"You've been a trooper, and you're committed like the rest of us," said JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert, pointing out that at the end of this budget the state will have its lowest structural deficit in the last decade. "We're going the right way, you'll have to admit that, but we won't get there over night."

Barrett in the House

Milwaukee Mayor Tom Barrett, who held a press conference earlier today in the Assembly Parlor, has stopped by the Joint Finance Committee session. Barrett is chatting with Sen. Russ Decker, Decker staffer Barb Worcester, and Rep. Pedro Colon.

JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert stopped the proceedings to recognize Barrett, asking whether he'd ever served on the budget committee when he was in the Legislature.

"I stayed away from it," Barrett replied, drawing laughs.

"That must be why everybody likes him," said Kaufert.

Doyle's IT Consolidation Approved

Though they shot down Gov. Doyle's attorney consolidation proposal, JFC members were feeling much more generous toward his plan to consolidate state information technology server and network support services from 24 state agencies in the Department of Administration

(Budget paper 111. The committee selected alternatives #2, 3, 4 and 5.)

The motion passed 16-0.

Doyle's Attorney Shift Denied

The Joint Finance Committee voted 15-1 to delete Gov. Doyle's recommendation to transfer certain executive branch state agency attorney and legal staff positions to the Department of Administration by next year.

The committee also opted to require DOA to delete 13 executive branch attorney positions.

(Budget paper 110. The committee chose alternative #5, but changed the date for eliminating the 13 attorney positions to June 30, 2007.)

Rep. Pedro Colon, the only no vote, said the governor knows best how to run his administration and should be allowed to do so. But Rep. Dean Kaufert replied: "We just believe this consolidation puts too much in one place."

Medical Assistance Put on Back Burner

With the committee back in session, Medicaid has been pushed back due to a few key issues JFC Republicans can't come to agreement on.

"There are a couple unresolved issues, but we do plan on finishing up today and getting it done today," said JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert.

Like last week when stem cells became an issue during the committee's action on the Building Commission appropriations, talks on the medical assistance package have stalled due to a push to have the Medicaid Family Planning Waiver program removed from the budget, an insider says. Planned Parenthood of Wisconsin has anticipated the move by distributing a fact sheet on the program, which was started by former GOP Gov. Tommy Thompson to provide low-income women to receive family planning services.

Two Minute Warning

JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert announced the committee will reconvene in two minutes.

Dems Still Waiting for Peek at Motion

As of 3:30, JFC Democrats still haven't received a copy of the Medical Assistance package Republicans have been working on. Co-Chair Dean Kaufert promised the Democrats, who have a 4-12 minority on the committee, a chance to look at the motion before voting on it would begin. That was when the committee broke at 11:30.

Some Dems on the committee reported that Republican members weren't happy with Kaufert's offer to give the minority party members a chance at an early perusal of the motion.

Committee Still Out

The Joint Finance Committee remains in a recess. Word is Senate and Assembly Republicans can't come to a consensus on the Medical Assistance package, but a source close to the talks says he still fully expects the committee to get it together and vote on it yet today.

There's little hope that things will be underway soon. The only JFC member present in the hearing room is Rep. Kitty Rhoades, who took the lead for the Assembly Republicans on Medicare.

Break Goes On

Though JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert promised committee Democrats a chance to view a draft of the Republican medical assistance proposal, it appears the GOP members are still working on the motion. Sources in the Dem offices say they haven't received a draft, and members of the press have also been waiting for a draft.

Kaufert had intended for the committee to reconvene at 1:30, but that time has passed and there's no sign that the committee will be back in soon.

Committee Breaks Until 1:30 to Mull Over Medical Assistance

JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert has sent the committee on a recess so Democrats can look over a draft of the Republican proposal for medical assistance funding. The committee is scheduled to come back at 1:30 p.m.

Kaufert said the paper is a draft because "we're still figuring out one or two things with regards to it."

The committee also hopes to take up technical colleges, Gov. Doyle's proposal to transfer departmental attorneys to the Department of Administration, utility aid payments under shared revenue, and non-point bonding, Kaufert said.

Hmong Cultural Center Idea Razed

An attempt to build a cultural center for the Hmong community has been defeated.

Kaufert proposed alternative #2, which proposed the building a $4.5 million Hmong Cultural Center and providing $2 million in general fund supported general obligation bonding to construct it. However, he removed the city of Madison as the designated location for the center. (Budget paper 191).


The motion failed 6-10.

"You don't lower bonding levelsby adding more bonding," said Sen. Robert Cowles. "Yeah, it's only $2 million, but there are a lot of ethnicities out there, are we going to build a cutlural center for every group that comes along?"

"If memory serves me, this proposal came from your side of the aisle," Kaufert said to Cowles. "No it didn't come from you, but it came from your side of the aisle."

Meeting Starts with Stabilization Fund Transfers

The Joint Finance Committee is underway. The committee will first deal with Assembly Bill 438 and Senate Bill 216, which extend funding for state programs with an anticipated shortfall in the 2003-05 biennium.

Included in the bill are $7.3 million fr corrections energy costs, $22.5 million for UW System energy costs, $75 million for medical assistance, and $2 million for SeniorCare. The amendments passed unanimously.

Rep. David Ward asked when the state could expect payment from the Ho-Chunk tribe, money that was supposed bridge some of this gap. He asked why the money isn't available, and when it will be.

Gov. Doyle's budget director Dave Schmiedicke said the Ho-Cunk payment would be made the next biennium, as the governor indicated in his budget bill.

"If discussions don't come to some voluntary payment to fulfill the compacts, there is an arbitration clause in the compact that they will have to be satisfied," Schmiedicke assured.

He said elements of the compacts amendments have been invalidated state Supreme Court decisions, and negotiations are ongoing as to how to reconcile those decisions with the compact.

Ten Minute Warning

It's been announced that the committee will meet in 10.

Starting Late

It's 10 o'clock, and the committee room is empty save for the committee clerk, pages and a few lobbyists. There are no committee members or staff in sight. No word yet on when today's session will begin.

Monday, June 06, 2005

No Meeting Tuesday

The Joint Finance co-chairs announced that tomorrow will be spent in working groups as committee members try to find harmony on the crucial areas still left in the budget: schools, medical assistance, transportation funding and taxes.

"We hope to do the preliminary work and get it done tomorrow so Wednesday and Thursday we can get through it smoother," said JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert.

The Wednesday agenda also includes AB 438/SB 216, legislation drafted after the release of the revised LFB estimates last month to address anticipated shortfalls in certain state programs for the remainder of the 2003-2005 biennium.

See the Wednesday agenda.

Committee Struggles with Choice School Teacher Credentials

Sen. Lena Taylor's motion to require all teachers participating in the Milwaukee parental choice program to have earned a high school diploma or equivalent certification seems like an easy pass for the Joint Finance Committee.

"I would hope that any legislator up here would say, 'If you're teaching our children, you should at least have a diploma,'" an incredulous Taylor said. She added she's seen "crack-addicted people who don't have diplomas teaching children" in some Milwaukee schools.

But Sen. Alberta Darling said complications come in when one defines teacher. She said a provision like the one Taylor suggested could exclude some parents who provide instruction in the program. "On first glance it looks extremely reasonable and then when you look at the definition (of teacher), it becomes very questionable," she said.

Taylor also offered a motion that would require the highest administrator at any Milwaukee parental choice program school to have at least two years of post-secondary education in an education-related field or a degree from an accredited institution of higher learning. That motion failed 10-4 on a party line vote.

Rep. Jeff Stone suggested the motions would be better handled through the legislative process and vowed to work with Taylor.

Taylor and JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald stepped out of the meeting to iron out a compromise and came back with a motion that required "all persons who are responsible for the academic instruction of pupils" at Milwaukee parental choice schools have a high school diploma or the equivalent. Even Darling signed on to the motion, but before they could vote Rep. Pedro Colón offered his own version because he said there was concern that Taylor, in her efforts to find a compromise, softened her position too much.

Colón's motion called for all persons responsible for academic instruction at choice schools to have a baccalaureate degree. The motion failed on a party line vote 10-4.

However, it must have thrown some members for a loop, because the committee took a 20 minute break to clear its collective head.

The bill was reworked to define the subjects under question as "teachers with primary responsibility for the academic instruction of pupils." The vote on the Taylor-Fitzgerald-Darling motion was 14-0.

Missing: Two Senators

Aides had to track down JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald and his Senate colleague Lena Taylor to vote on a motion from Sen. Alberta Darling. The pair were in a room trying to reach a deal on a Taylor motion from earlier that would require Milwaukee parental choice program teachers to have a high school diploma or the equivalency. (More on this later.)

The Darling motion to require the Department of Public Instruction to submit proposals for expenditure of administrative funds for federal programs for a 14-day passive review by the JFC beginning in 2006-07. The motion passed 8-6, with Fitzgerald voting yes and Taylor voting no.

Quotable Colón

"The biggest problem we have in school choice today is they're hitting the caps." Rep. Pedro Colón.

"We don't live in a lab, we live in a city. And we are not a chemistry set, we are families." Colón commenting on the experimental nature of the school choice program.

Colón proposed a motion to prohibit any more students from transferring into or out of the Milwaukee Public Schools system under the open enrollment program. Stopping the flow of kids out of the district (in 2003-04 108 students have transferred into MPS, while 2,520 have left) would return more than $50 million to the city of Milwaukee, Colon claimed. The motion failed 8-6.

Leibham Out

Sen. Joe Leibham left for the day to attend a previously scheduled meeting with school district officials in Plymouth.

Dems edge closer to that elusive majority.

Charter School Argument Continues

Sen. Russ Decker is continuing to oppose funding initiatives for charter schools, saying his home district has school districts that in the same boat or worse off than Milwaukee and Racine.

Decker got in a brief spat with Sen. Alberta Darling over the nature of the schools.

"Charter schools are public schools," said Darling, who had the floor.

"No they're not," Decker replied.

"Yes they are," said Darling.

"Not in Milwaukee and Racine they're not," said Decker.

"Yes they are," Darling said.

JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald tapped his gavel to get back to order before voices were raised. He asked an Legislative Fiscal Bureau representative to settle the argument, but the best the LFB worker could do was say that "charter schools are subject to some of the laws that govern other school districts."

"You sounded a lot like a politician there, but you were put in a tough spot," Fitzgerald said.

Decker, Taylor Battle GOP Over School Choice Funding

Senate Dems on the committee failed in their attempt to get the school choice program to be funded under the same restraints as public schools.

Sen. Russ Decker was pushing for alternative #3 in budget paper 625, which would hold the per pupil increase for charter and choice schools to the amount allowed for public schools under revenue limits, saving the state $8.1 million in the biennium. It was defeated 13-2. Sen. Alberta Darling championed alternative #4, which would maintain current law. It passed 13-2.

"All we keep getting is open-ended requests for cash," said Sen. Russ Decker of the state's choice and charter program. He said the program has "zero accountability to the state."

JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert said most legislators support greater accountability measures, but "they just don't seem to get passed into law any time."

Sen. Lena Taylor said accountability measures proposed to the Legislature are tainted by "bad apples" from outside the system that have interests other than what's best for the students. She said the bad apples need to be "kicked out of the bucket."

Darling said the charter schools have higher graduation rates than their public school counterparts. "The purpose of choice is to provide competition so low-income parents can get their children the best education possible," she said. But the Dems argued that the playing field for isn't level among choice schools and public schools.

DOR to Create, Maintain Tax Scofflaw List

The committee deleted provisions from Gov. Doyle's budget bill relating to posting names of delinquent taxpayers on the Internet, replacing it with language from 2005 Assembly Bill 330. The motion passed 15-0 and was authored by JFC Co-Chairs Scott Fitzgerald and Dean Kaufert.

AB 330 requires the Department of Revenue to maintain a list of all delinquent taxpayers and post the names on a site created by the department. The list will be limited to people who owe taxes, interest, penalties fees or costs in excess of $25,000.

The DOR would be required to update the list on a quarterly basis.

Taylor's O-for-2

Two motions by Sen. Lena Taylor to improve health care for her constituents were rejected on party line votes.

Taylor first moved to provide $200,000 GPR over the biennium for the Milwaukee Immediate Care Center in Milwaukee, which serves about 11,000 low income patients. The money was intended to support day-to-day costs.

Next, a motion to increase annual funding for minority health grants by $100,000 each year was denied, as was the prior one, on a 4-11 vote.

HIRSP Administration Gets Retooled

The Department of Health and Family Services no longer has oversight over the the health insurance risk-sharing plan following a motion to radically change HIRSP passed 13-2. The motion was authored by Reps. Kitty Rhoades and Dean Kaufert, and Sens. Alberta Darling and Mary Lazich.

Under current law, HIRSP provides insurance to people with adverse medical histories and others who can't get health care coverage. Currently, HIRSP is administered by DHFS and a 13-member board of governors.

The motion changes HIRSP into a legally distinc, nonprofit organization governed by a 13-member board of directors nominated by teh Commisioner of Insurance. DHFS would have no role in the new HIRSP program.

The motion eliminates 4.83 SEG positions effective at the beginning of next year.

Session Begins

Committee is called to order. Rep. Scott Jensen is absent today, and word is the committee will take up school choice, votes Jensen would have to recuse himself of anyway due to his involvement with a school choice group. (Jensens paper butterflies, colored with crayon by his children, are present, however.)

Sen. Lena Taylor is also absent at the beginning of the meeting, but arrives at 2:20 p.m. and is counted as present.

Mostly "cats and dogs" items expected today, according to sources inside the committee. There are rumors that the committee won't meet formally and will use the day to hammer out packages on transporation, education and medical assistance. The committe chairs said that is an option and may announce their intention by the end of the day.

Two O'Clock Start for JFC

JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald just announced the committee will convene at 2 p.m.

JFC Meeting Starting Late ...

but it may not be long. JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert popped into the hearing room a few minutes ago and things should get started "very soon." Interpret that how you wish.

Friday, June 03, 2005

Next Week's JFC Meeting Agenda Released

Check out the list of agencies in front of JFC next week.



JOINT COMMITTEE ON FINANCE



EXECUTIVE SESSIONS

MONDAY, JUNE 6, 2005 (1:00 P.M.)
TUESDAY, JUNE 7, 2005 (10:00 A.M.)
WEDNESDAY, JUNE 8, 2005 (10:00 A.M.)


The Joint Committee on Finance will meet in Executive Session on Monday, June 6, 2005 (1:00 p.m.), Tuesday, June 7, 2005 (10:00 a.m.), and Wednesday, June 8, 2005 (10:00 a.m.) on the 2005-07 biennial budget. The meeting will be held in Room 412 East, State Capitol. The Executive Sessions will be held on the budgets of the following agencies:


Department of Employee Trust Funds (Pending Motion)

Department of Corrections
• Adult Corrections -- Pilot Program for Inmates with Mental Illness (Pending Motion)

Department of Administration
• Transfers to the Department
• Division of Gaming

Office of the Commissioner of Insurance

Department of Health and Family Services -- HIRSP and Public Health

Department of Health and Family Services -- Medical Assistance, BadgerCare, and SeniorCare -- Eligibility, Payments, and Services



Department of Health and Family Services
• Medical Assistance, BadgerCare, and SeniorCare -- Administration: MA Contracts and CARES Funding (Page 258, Item #1)
• Community, Disability, and Elder Services: Community Aids (Page 279, Item #1)
• Medical Assistance -- Long-Term Care: Nursing Home Rates and Bed Assessment Increase (Paper #385)

Department of Health and Family Services -- Base Reestimates and Funding (Page 237, #5 and Page 238, #6)

Miscellaneous Appropriations (Only Items Contained in AB 100)

Office of the Lieutenant Governor

Budget Management and Compensation Reserves

Budget Stabilization Fund

Building Commission -- Transfer to Budget Stabilization Fund (Paper #183)

Building Program -- Hmong Cultural Center (Paper #191)
• Pending Motions

General Fund Taxes
• Tax Administration
• Individual and Corporate Income Taxes
• General Sales and Use Tax (Pending Motions)
• Utility and Miscellaneous Taxes (Pending Motions)

Shared Revenue and Tax Relief
• Direct Aid Payments
• Property Tax Credits
• Property Taxation

University of Wisconsin System -- Transfer to Laboratory of Hygiene (Page 505, Item #30)

Wisconsin Technical College System -- (Pending Motion)



Department of Public Instruction
• General School Aids and Revenue Limits
• Categorical Aids
• Choice and Charter
• Administrative and Other Funding

Department of Transportation
• Transportation Finance
• Local Transportation Aids
• Local Transportation Projects
• State Highway Program

Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection and Natural Resources
• Nonpoint Account Appropriations
• Nonpoint Program Bonding (Paper #553)

Department of Commerce -- Petroleum Inspection Fund (Paper #214)

JFC Adjourns Until Monday

The committee adjourned at about 3:20 p.m. Next week, meetings are scheduled to begin at 1 p.m. on Monday, and 10 a.m. on Tuesday and Wednesday.

JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert said, "Hopefully Thursday will be the ending date if things go right."

Jensen's Butterflies Add Color to Hearing Room

Rep. Scott Jensen's butterflies are multiplying.

Yesterday, the former Assembly speaker taped a picture of a purple butterfly his 4-year-old daughter colored for him on the front of his desk at JFC. The picture adds a little color to the normally drab JFC surroundings.

An newspaper ran a short online story on the picture, and Jensen read it to his daughter. His son overheard, and wondered why the butterfly picture he made wasn't represented as wel.

Today, Jensen has two butterflies hanging from his desk.

Fitzgerald: "Budget Is Not the Appropriate Place" for Stem Cell Policy

JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald closed the door on a motion that would have brought the debate over stem cell research into the budget.

Yesterday, Wisconsin Right to Life sent a memo to JFC members "protect taxpayers from being forced to support the destruction of human embryos for research and the cloning of human embryos for any reason." The memo sparked a frenzy of speculation that committee Republicans would draft and introduce a motion to bar state funds or facilities from being used for stem cell research.

Fitzgerald said he and his colleagues met with representatives from the UW and other interested groups to discuss the issue, and after consideration decided not to bring a motion to the JFC.

"It seems to me the state budget is not the appropriate place to have this debate," Fitzgerald said, adding a separate bill will be introduced sometime soon, and the issue will get the full-scale debate it deserves.

Fitzgerald's full statement

There was a brief discussion on budget paper 186, which includes $137.5 million for the Wisconsin Institute for Discovery, the facility that is proposed as a site for stem cell research. The vote passed 12-4, with GOP Sens. Fitzgerald, Mary Lazich, Robert Cowles and Joe Liebham voting in opposition.

Building Program Bonding Slashed by $30 Million

Committee Republicans carved $30 million from the Building Commission's proposed bonding schedule.

Budget paper 186

The JFC voted 12-4, along partisan lines, to reduce the Building Commission's "other public purposes" bonding authorization by $20 million, and the UW System's GPR supported bonding by $10 million.

Sen. Robert Cowles said the borrowing should be slashed much more severely than what the co-chairs proposed.

"It's nice to knock down the $30 million, but we should go much further," Cowles said.

Kaufert's Forestry and Park Motion Passes

The JFC unanimously approved a motion that provides more than $2.3 million in payments to local governments whose taxation district contains land enrolled as closed acreage under MFL. Each municipality will pay their county treasurer 20 percent of the amount received.

Overall, the motion allocated a total of $4.6 million SEG to various projects.

The DNR will get $587,000 annually from the forestry account to pay for estimated overtime costs related to forest fire management. The motion, authored by JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert, also provides $200,000 over the biennium to North Central Technical College and Fox Valley Technical College to initiate a program to train students to use mechanized equipment for harvesting timber.

In addition, $100,000 forestry fund money will be provided to the Paper Industry Hall of Fame to support the development and operation of the Paper Discover Center in Appleton.

No Motion on Stem Cell Funding Ban

There will not be a motion before the Joint Finance Committee to prohibit the use of state funding or facilities for stem cell research. The motion was backed by Wisconsin Right to Life.

The first budget paper the committee took up was no. 551 on DNR water resources account adjustments.

Five Minutes to Curtain

JFC Co-Chair has announced that the committee will convene in five minutes.

Stem Cell Research Still Slowing Committee Work

The pre-meeting debate over a motion to prohibit state money and facilities from being used in stem cell research has got the committee tied in knots. Now it sounds as if the motion doesn't have the votes to pass, and there's a good chance a motion will into be offered.

A source inside the talks said committee members who vote against it would oppose it on grounds it is a non-fiscal policy item aimed at prohibiting stem cell research. "They could have done it as policy because they have a commitment from legislators to support it. But this is really a big screw you to Governor Doyle at the expense of some members of the committee who don't want to support it."

Legislative leaders were meeting with Wisconsin Right to Life leaders this morning as well to try to figure out a solution. "In the end, putting out those memos may have hurt Right to Life's cause more than it helped it," said the Senate insider.

WRTL memo to JFC members

Stem Cell Debate May Slow Session Start

Half past nine and the JFC Hearing room is virtually empty - just some pages, lobbyists and a couple overly-optimistic reporters. No sign yet of committee members or their staff. The meeting was set to begin at 9 a.m., but the co-chairs said that was a "soft nine."

There's a light agenda today, but it could get complicated as Wisconsin Right to Life and sympathetic legislators is pushing committee members to introduce a motion that would prohibit the use of state funds or facilities for stem cell research.

But a source close to the committee said while the motion would be brought up during deliberations on the Building Commission budget, there's no certainty that it will be.

"Right to Life kind of jumped the gun yesterday with those press releases because nothing is even drafted," said the source. "We don't know what the motion really does, and we don't even know if there's nine votes to get it out of committee."

Friday Agenda Includes Building Commission and Program, DNR Issues

Below, check out what's on tap for the JFC today.



JOINT COMMITTEE ON FINANCE



EXECUTIVE SESSION

FRIDAY, JUNE 3, 2005 (9:00 A.M.)


The Joint Committee on Finance will meet in Executive Session on Friday, June 3, 2005, at 9:00 a.m. on the 2005-07 biennial budget. The meeting will be held in Room 412 East, State Capitol. The Executive Sessions will be held on the budgets of the following agencies:



Building Commission

Building Program

Department of Natural Resources -- Water Quality: Water Resources Account Adjustments (Paper #551)

Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection and DNR -- Water Quality: Nonpoint Program Bonding (Paper #553)

Department of Natural Resources -- Forestry and Parks (Pending Motion)

Thursday, June 02, 2005

Corrections Complete, Committee Adjourns

The JFC spent an entire day on the Department of Corrections, reversing some of Gov. Doyle's proposals while staying with his recommendations on others.

See postings below for more details.

Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald said the committee will get an early start tomorrow, convening at 9 a.m. The hope is to adjourn early, he said.

"Is that a hard nine or a soft nine?" asked his Co-Chair Dean Kaufert.

"What, in finance? A soft nine," Fitzgerald replied.

Back in Action

After a lengthy break, the committee is continuing to take up free-standing motions on the Department of Corrections budget. The committee is planning to make an early day of it because some members have family commitments to attend this evening. No word yet on what time tomorrow's meeting will begin.

JFC Eliminates 59 Corrections Positions

Saving nearly $9 million over the biennium, the committee voted unanimously to eliminate 59 Department of Corrections unit supervisor and assistant unit supervisor positions. The motion, authored by JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald, also prohibits corrections from creating or employing any more unit supervisors or similar positions to supervise correctional institution security staff if that position does not directly report to the institution's security director. The motion passed 16-0.

Sex Offender Registration Fee Adopted

Following Gov. Jim Doyle's recommendation and going one better, the JFC voted unanimously to delete more than $700,000 for chemical treatment for child sex offenders.

The committee chose to adopt alernatives 1 and 2 in budget paper 231.


Next, the committee adopted Doyle's recommendation to allow the Department of Corrections to establish a sex offender registration fee not to exceed $50. The fee will be used to partially offset the costs of monitoring. Estimated revenue is $478,200 PR in 2005-06 and $504,700 PR in 2006-07.

Budget paper 232

Governor Trash Talk in JFC

A little partisan gubernatorial trash talking seeped into the proceedings today. Dem Sen. Russ Decker's heavy criticism of the private business/business employment program drew a hopeful response from one Republican.

"Well, maybe Gov. Walker or Gov. Green will make it better," said JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald.

"It'll be a long time before they get a chance to do that," responded Sen. Lena Taylor.

Earned Release Program Expansion Killed

A bold initiative in Gov. Jim Doyle's budget, the provision to expand te earned release program in the Department of Corrections, was killed by the JFC on a partisan 12-4 vote.

Details in budget paper 226

JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert said the committee opted to keep the program as it is for now because it was too early to judge its success. While 114 inmates out of 150 have successfully completed the program, he said he's unwilling to take chances on the two-year-old program. "I for one need more time for the department to show me that it works," he said. "I need more data, I need more facts to show me that I'm not going to get burned by this."

Democrats countered that incarceration isn't appropriate for many crimes, and often nonviolent offenders become hardened criminals due to exposure to prison. "You may not know this, but they call it criminal college," said Sen. Lena Taylor.

$12 Million Deleted from Prison Contract Beds Appropriations

The committee adopted Gov. Doyle's recommendation to delete $4,314,300 GPR in 2005-06 and $7,827,300 GPR in 2006-07 related to in-state and out-of-state contract beds, and transfer $500,500 GPR annually from purchase of service funding to contract bed funding.

In addition, the State Building Commission and the Department of Corrections were directed to prepare a 10-year facilities strategic plan for the correctional facilities. The plan will be funded from the building trust.

Budget paper 225

In a related motion, the committee voted 11-5 to provide annual GPR funding of $1.5 million for in-state and out-of-state prison contract beds. The funding was placed in the JFC's supplemental appropriation.

Sen. Russ Decker said the money would be better spent on Badgercare and school aids, not making prisoners more comfortable. "I don't have a lot of sympathy for folks who break the law," Decker said.

While he said he agreed with Decker's sentiments, Fitzgerald said, "We have a responsibility certainly to the corrections officers who work in these institutions to provide them a safe environment."

Prison Health Care Privatization Jettisoned

On a unanimous vote, the JFC turned down Gov. Jim Doyle's proposal to privatize health care services for state inmates. "It was a bold move by the governor, but I ust don't think we're ready for it at this point," said JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald.

The committee chose alternative B1 in budget paper 221, which reads as follows: "Delete the Governor's recommendation regarding health care staffing. Transfer $12,789,300 GPR in 2006-07 associated with the 124.45 GPR positions to the Committee's supplemental appropriation. Direct the Department to submit a plan, not later than January 2, 2006, regarding the manner in which the Department will manage correctional health care and health care costs in 2006-07. If the Department intends to contract for health care, the plan should specify the contract provisions and costs. If the Department does not contract for health care, the plan should specify how Corrections will address correctional health care needs. Funding could be released and positions adjusted after the plan is approved by the Committee."

Budget paper 221


The committee voted 14-2 to create a pilot program under which a private contractor would supply and distribute at one DOC adult institution. The motion dictates that a contract will only be rewarded ifa cost savings is realized as a result of the contractor.

Short Day Made Shorter By Late Start

The meeting was called to order just after 1 p.m. The meeting was scheduled to begin at 11 a.m.

The JFC will begin with Department of Corrections appropriations, then take a break and move on to building commission if time allows.

JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald said the committee is on a short schedule today, but will convene tomorrow.

Committee Start Delayed

The JFC is waiting for motions to be drafted by Legislative Fiscal Bureau Staff. "Obviously we need those people to be out here with us. But the committee is ready to go," joked JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald.

Committee members spent much of the morning working on Department of Corrections budget items, sources say. Also expected to be taken up today are budget papers related to the building program.

Revised JFC Agenda for Thursday

Read below for the revised agenda for Thursday's Joint Finance session, revised to reflect Wednesday's action.


JOINT COMMITTEE ON FINANCE

EXECUTIVE SESSION

THURSDAY, JUNE 2, 2005 (11:00 A.M.)

The Joint Committee on Finance will meet in Executive Session on Thursday, June 2, 2005, at 11:00 a.m. on the 2005-07 biennial budget. The meeting will be held in Room 412 East, State Capitol. The Executive Sessions will be held on the budgets of the following agencies:

Department of Employee Trust Funds (Pending Motion)

Department of Administration -- General Agency Provisions: Transfer from the Public Benefits Fund (Paper #100)

Department of Veterans Affairs -- Homes and Facilities for Veterans: Veterans Home at Union Grove -- Fuel and Utilities (Page 521, Item #7)

Department of Health and Family Services -- HIRSP and Public Health

Department of Health and Family Services -- Medical Assistance, BadgerCare, and SeniorCare -- Eligibility, Payments, and Services

Department of Health and Family Services
  • State-Operated Institutions: Fuel and Utilities (Page 279, Item #9)
  • Medical Assistance, BadgerCare, and SeniorCare -- Administration: MA Contracts and CARES Funding (Page 258, Item #1)
  • Community, Disability, and Elder Services: Community Aids (Page 279, Item #1)
Lieutenant Governor

Wisconsin Technical College System -- (Pending Motion)

University of Wisconsin System

Higher Educational Aids Board

Shared Revenue

  • Direct Aid Payments
  • Property Tax Credits
  • Property Taxation

Public Instruction



  • General School Aids and Revenue Limits
  • Categorical Aids
  • Choice and Charter
  • Administrative and Other Funding

Transportation



  • Transportation Finance
  • Local Transportation Aids
  • Local Transportation Projects
  • State Highway Program

Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection and Natural Resources



  • Nonpoint Account Appropriations

Department of Natural Resources -- Water Quality: Water Resources Account Adjustments (Paper #551)

Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection and DNR -- Water Quality: Nonpoint Program Bonding (Paper #553)

Department of Natural Resources -- Forestry and Parks (Pending Motion)

Department of Commerce -- Petroleum Inspection Fund (Paper #214)

Building Commission

Building Program

Department of Corrections -- Departmentwide

Department of Corrections -- Adult Corrections

Wednesday, June 01, 2005

Committee Adjourns

The JFC adjourned at about 7 p.m. They'll be back at 11 a.m.

$37 Million Public Benefits Transfer Approved

As Sen. Luther Olsen put it, the fox always knows where the henhouse is. "We will always raid this fund," he said, referring to the utilities public benefits fund.

The transfer has been one of the most heavily lobbied of the budget deliberations, with big energy companies and business partnering with environmental groups to oppose Gov. Doyle's proposal to transfer $18 million in 2005-06 and $17 million in 2006-07.

But the committee, heavily loaded with Republicans who blasted the governor for fund transfers, passed the governor's proposal 12-4, then tacked on an extra $2 million for good measure.

Sen. Robert Cowles said moving the money "from people's utility bills" to cover general fund expenses is a mistake. He reminded committee members of the $47 million that was transferred from the fund in the last budget.

"I guess I'm passionate about efficiency and waste," Cowles said. "When you pay more on rate-based energy, it's waste."

Sen. Russ Decker, who with Dem Rep. Mark Pocan and GOP Sens. Cowles and Alberta Darling voted against the transfer, admonished the Republicans who voted for the motion for "chastising Gov. Doyle. "Raids have been going on and have since Tommy Thompson. I think he was the master of it," he said.

JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert, like many of those who voted yes, did so reluctantly.

"In a perfect world, I wouldn't want to go here either, but we're in tough times," he said.

The committee voted 12-4 on a bipartisan vote to transfer $1.9 million over the biennium to DHFS from the utility public benefits to support a one-time increase for income maintenance contracts. The motion was authored by Dem Rep. Pedro Colon.

Rest of Tonight's Agenda Set

After a five minute break that lasted an hour, the JFC came back at around 6:30 p.m. to tackle a few more issues. The committee will handle "cats and dogs" issues like the Department of Veteran Affairs fuel and utilities funding, and the Department of Health and Family Services fuel and utilities funding and community aids.

The big gun will be public benefits, outlined in budget paper 100.

The issue has drawn a lot of interest from lobbyists, and has business interests and environmental groups decrying the governor's planned transfers of more than $35 million. Talk around the room is not only will the committee approve the transfer from the program, which is unpopular with many Republicans, but pack on $2 million more to the transfer.

Kaufert Gets Razzed for Bringing Home the Bacon

A motion by JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert to spend $105,000 on his home region UW-Fox Valley provoked "oinking" noises from staffers and legislators.

Kaufert said the motion comes from the contingency of Fox Valley lawmakers. Plexus Corp. of Neenah, one of Fox Valley's largest employers, is finding it harder to find quality electrical engineering students to hire in the Fox Valley, he explained. So Plexus is willing to provide $500,000 in equipment to start a collaborative electrical engineering program between UW-Fox Valley and UW-Oshkosh. The state would provide the $105,000 in 2006-07.

Sounds legit, but members still gave him a hard time. Snorting sounds were heard as the measure was introduced, and Dem Rep. Mark Pocan remarked, "Pedro (Colon) was wondering if we should rename the Fox Valley the Pork Valley."

Colon responded in mock defense, "I have not said a word."

The motion passed 14-2, with Dem Sen. Lena Taylor voting, "Yes, oink oink."

Ball Rolling on Campus Merger

A task force to study and develop an implementation plan forthe transformation of UW-Waukesha into a campus of UW-Milwaukee will get $30,000 from the state to help them along.

The motion was authored by Rep. Scott Jensen and Sens. Alberta Darling and Mary Lazich. The task force will be made up of nine members and must issue its recommendations to the JFC by Jan. 1, 2007. The motion passed 11-5, with JFC Co-Chair Dean Kaufert voting with the four Democrats.

Jensen also proposed a study on potential joint academic programs between UW-Milwaukee and the Medical College of Wisconsin. Findings are to be reported by Jan. 1, 2007. The motion passed 16-0.

In other campus collaboration news, the committee will later take up a motion direct UW System to create a task force study collaborative efforts between UW-Superior and its neighbors at the University of Minnesota-Duluth, which is just 8.6 miles away, according to Jensen.

Jensen cited the "Tri-College program" involving North Dakota State University, Minnesota State University at Moorehead, and Concordia College in Moorehead, Minn., as an example of how a interstate partnership can work.

Under the motion, the UW System is stipulated to report findings to the JFC by March 1 of next year.

The motion passed 16-0.

Slackers Beware

Flunking a UW System class is going to cost you big bucks. A motion written by Rep. David Ward imposes a 100 percent per credit surcharge on classes that are retaken because of a failure on the first attempt.

Ward argued that taxpayers should not have to subsidize poor performance. But GOP Rep. Kitty Rhoades argued that some required course work for majors may not be to each students strengths. She cited her experience with Spanish in college. "I learned I'm not a language person," she said.

The measure narrowly passed 9-7.

Another measure aimed at slacking students passed 16-0. It requires the UW System Board of Regents to charge students the full cost-per-credit for any credits beyon 125 percent of graduationcredit requirements toward a first baccalaureate degree. Under current policy, students who have accumulated more than 165 credits will be assessed a 100 percent surcharge.

Pocan Tilts at the Windmills

On the heels of a major cut package in UW System funding, Rep. Mark Pocan's attempts to keep student costs at UW schools down fell far short.

Pocan proposed providing $8.8 million annually for WHEG-UW funding. Just an hour ago, the committee had voted to reduce the funding by $11 million over the next two years. His motion failed 14-2, with Rep. Pedro Colon his only supporter.

Next, he proposed a resident undergraduate tuition freeze over the biennium that would burden the state with an additional $90 million in GPR. "I heard there was a contest for the largest budget amendment, so I put this together," he joked. The motion failed 15-1.

UW License Fee Increase Fails

A proposed hike of the University of Wisconsin campus license plates from $20 to $25 was beaten by a bipartisan 6-10 vote. The increase, proposed by Sen. Luther Olsen, would have generated more than $60,000 for scholarships over the biennium, the Legislative Fiscal Bureau estimated.

UW System Warned: No ROTC, No GPR for You

Not wanting to see a repeat of what happened recently at UW Stout, the Joint Finance Committee approved a drastic penalty for any school that would keep reserve officer training corps from campus.

JFC Co-Chair Sen. Scott Fitzgerald and Rep. Dan Meyer proposed the motion, which passed 15-1. Democratic Rep. Mark Pocan was the only no vote.

UW Funding Fight Not Over

An avalanche of motions are sitting in front of the Joint Finance Committee. Fifteen motions have been introduced dealing with everything from the merger of the UW-Milwaukee and UW-Waukesha campuses, to restoration of WHEG funding and a tuition freeze, to an increase in UW campus license plates.

Stay tuned as the committee wades through this sea of papers.

UW System Package Passes

After a series of failed Democratic proposals, the Joint Finance Committee voted 12-4 along party lines to cut $45 million and 118 jobs from the UW System budget proposed by Gov. Jim Doyle. The $45 million figure includes cuts in student financial aid.

See details of the UW System package below.

Dems' Tuition Cap Move Fails

A proposed 3 percent tuition cap for the University of Wisconsin System in the 2005-07 state budget failed in a 12-4 party-line vote.

Affordability was the point of the Democratic counterproposals aimed at easing the financial burden the Republicans’ proposals might impose.

Sen. Russ Decker and Rep. Marc Pocan led the Democratic side of the tuition cap debate, calling the proposal a way to keep the institution’s doors open to less affluent. “We think this is a way to do it, to keep affordability in place,” Decker said.

Pocan chimed in and said the tuition increases of 15 and 18 percent last session were imposing hardship on students. “We are pricing families out of the UW System,” Pocan said, noting the “committee doesn’t seem to be able to show a commitment to the UW System.”

JFC Co-Chair Scott Fitzgerald said while the Republicans spent weeks on the proposal that “uses real money,” the Democrats devoted a few hours to a plan that sounds good but is not planted in reality.

"This tuition cap is one of the things that will help cripple the university," said Co-Chair Dean Kaufert.

Dems Fight Back - Call for Tuition Cap

The Democrats' counterproposal to the Republican cut package includes a reversion back to the governor's level of 15.8 percent annual increases in Wisconsin Higher Education Grant funding, and a 3 percent cap on UW System tuition in 2005-07. The motion decreases program revenue for the UW System by $49.6 million.

The Dem proposal also calls for the restoration of grant programs the Republicans targeted for cuts, like the Lawton Grant and the Advanced Opportunity Program Grants. It provides 6 percent annual funding increases for the WHEG Tech School funding.

Dems Develop Counter to Republican Cuts

The half-hour break to allow Democrats to delve into the UW System and Higher Education Aids budget cuts proposed by the Republicans is now approaching an hour and a half. The Dems went into a closed door meeting and will be emerging shortly with counter-motions to the Republicans' proposed cuts of $45 million from Gov. Doyle's biennial budget proposal.

Some Republican staffers are wondering why Dem Assembly Minority Leader Jim Kreuser, who has issued a couple of press releases criticizing committee Republicans for meeting behind closed doors, isn't raising hell.

"If he had any consistency at all he should be outraged at what members of his party have done today," said the staffer. "Evidently he's more interested in cheap political attacks."

Committee Breaks Until 12:15 to Mull Massive UW Cut Package

Committee Dems have asked for a break to look over a comprehensive motion that cuts Gov. Doyle's proposed Higher Educational Aids Board and UW System funding by a total of more than $45 million GPR over the biennium.

The motion was introduced by Rep. Dean Kaufert and Sen. Scott Fitzgerald, JFC co-chairs. Democrats Rep. Mark Pocan and Sen. Russ Decker asked for the break to look at the 18-part motion, saying they hadn't seen the proposal until 11:30.

Among the proposed cuts: $3.4 million in 2005-06 and $7.5 million in 2006-07 from the Doyle proposal for funding the WHEG-UW program, which would provide a 6 percent annual funding increase. (Budget paper 440)

- Increases of $642,000 in 2005-06 and $1.3 million in 2006-07 for the WHEG program for Wisconsin Technical College System students, providing an increase of 6 percent annually. (Budget paper 440)

- Reduce funding for fuel and utilities for the UW System by $902,500 over the biennium. (Budget paper 775)

- Restore 100 GPR positions in 2005-06 and modify the governor's recommendations by deleting an additional $15 million GPR in 2005-06 and $10 million GPR in 2006-07. In addition, specify that $1.5 million annually of this reduction be from the UW System administration appropriation, which would represent an approximate 15 percent reduction to that appropriation. (Budget paper 776)

- Delete the governor's provision for funding for additional faculty, which would reduce GPR spending by $11.4 million in 2006-07 and by 120 GPR positions. (Budget paper 778)

- Reduce the governor's proposal for Alzheimer's research by $500,000 GPR in 2005-06. (Budget paper 780)




Budget papers 775-786

HEAB funding budget paper

Meeting Begins

Meeting is called to order at 11:30 a.m., just a half hour behind the scheduled time, a new standard for JFC promptness.

The first order of business is UW System funding and the Higher Education Aids Board.
Co-Chair Rep. Dean Kaufert said shared revenue, transportation and corrections will not be taken up today.

Turning Over a New Leaf?

It looks like things will be underway shortly at JFC. An announcement was made at 11 a.m. that the committee will meet in five minutes. Most of the Republican Assembly members were in their seats before the scheduled 11 o'clock meeting time, and senators started arriving shortly after their cacus broke up at 11.

Perhaps skipping yesterday's session, and caucuses by the GOP Assembly last night and GOP Senate this morning, help put some ducks in order?

Greg Bump

Contact: bump@wispolitics.com

Updates on Joint Finance Committee action on the 2007-09 Wisconsin state budget, from the first JFC meetings through the governor's final vetoes.

Site feed (RSS)

Powered by Blogger



A production of WisPolitics Publishing.